Bateson StepsToAnEcologyofMind

8/11/2019 Bateson StepsToAnEcologyofMind

1/360

"#$%" #& '(

$)&*&+, &- ./(0)&**$)#$0 $""'," /( '(#12&%&*&+,3 %",)1/'#2,3 $4&*5#/&(3

'(0 $%/"#$.&*&+,

!"#$%"& ()*#+%,

6789: ';9:89: /:?@7AB3 (BC 6B;8BD*9:E9:


2/360

F7AG:B8B %7G:>G:H I /E7 F7HJ8 0K7>G "J;7L F7>J7:3 MNOP Q !"#$%&'(') +, -./0


3/360

)9RD;GH?> S MNPT3 MNUP VD 6789: ';9:89: /:?G8 V99]\7D VB J8BE 9; ;BR;9EJ89B@B; CG>?9J> C;G>>B: RB;\G88G9:[;9\1$'2# "32#'2# 4#5, B^
G: >?B 7>G9:8 G: ;B@GBC8 [9; G:7A9HG:HaG:a%JVAGG9: 07>7

F7>B89:3 +;BH9;D=

">BR8 >9 7: B? 8


4/360

-./01/02

-./01/02 3M=M MNPM %2$-')$ XM=T MNUP %2$-')$ UM=O -&2$c&20 MWM=Z /(#2&05)#/&( MO

4 5)"* 67 8#*)9%$:#+ 4;T=M .B>7A9_JBb c?D 09 #?G:H8 +B> G: 7 .JEEABjk TT

T=T .B>7A9HJBb c?D 09 -;B:


5/360

Y=Z ' 2BaB^7\G:7>G9: 9[ dF7>B89:l8 2JABek TPWY=Y )9\\B:> 9: %7;> /4 TUZ

D 5)"* G7 1C@+*#>%9%$& ),? 1I%9%$& 4JDX=M )DVB;:B>G< $^RA7:7>G9:k TUPX=T 2BEJ:E7:


6/360

!"! !$%! &'()*+(

/ ?7@B VBB: 9:B 9[ +;BH9;D F7>B89:l8 8>JEB:>8 [9; >?;BB DB7;8 7:E / C78 7VAB >9?BAR ?G\ 8BAB >?B B887D8 C?G >9HB>?B; [9; >?B [G;8> >G\B G: 9:B@9AJ\B= / VBAGB@B >?7> >?G8 G8 7 @B;D G\R9;>7:> V99]3 :9> 9:AD [9; >?98B C?9 7;BR;9[B88G9:7AAD ?B VB?7@G9;7A 8G9: f >?B HB:B;7>G9: V9;: 8G: G> EGE >?B: >?B;B G8 :9 \B7:G:H G: G> 7> 7AA= / ]:9C >?7>RA7 >?B;B \D8BA[= '8 [7; 78 / ]:9C3 >?B;B 7;B 9:AD >C9 C7D8 9J>=

&:B G8 ;BAGHG9J8 ;GBE #79G8\= &>?B;8 7;B


7/360

>?B\ >?7> >?G:]G:H G8 C?7> D9J E9 C?B: D9J 8>JED 7 >B^>V99]= 'A893 >9 AB7;: >9 >?G:]3D9J \J8> ?7@B 7 >B7


8/360


9/360

-;B_JB:>AD 3 EJ;G:H ?G8 ;9EJG9: G:EGB83 +;BH9;D [BA> 78 G[ ?BCB;B 8RB7]G:H 7:E C;G>G:H G: 7 [9;BGH: A7:HJ7HB= %B9RAB EGE :9> 8G\RAD 7H;BB 9;EG87H;BB CG>? ?G\L >?BD CB;B VBCGAEB;BE 9; G:>9^GBE= .7;] $:HBA83 G: ?G8 MNPM%;B[7CBB: >?B d\G:E B^R7:EG:He B^RB;GB:BAABJ7A = /: ;B>;98RB G> 8>;G]B8 \B >?7>G:>9^GG9: 7:E ?B8B 7V8>;7 7:EEG[[G RGB


10/360

!". )/'(0/'1

"9\B \B: 8BB\ 7VAB >9 H9 9: C9;]G:H 8>B7EGAD CG>? AG>>AB 8J?B8B= / ?7@B :BBEBE >9 ]:9C >?7>89\BV9ED BA8B VBAGB@BE >?7> \D C9;] ?7E R;9\G8B 7:E EG;BG9:3 7:E / ?7@B 9[>B:VBB: 8J;R;G8BE >?7> 9>?B;8 ?7E [7G>? G: \B C?B: / ?7E @B;D AG>>AB G: \D8BA[= / ?7@B3 7>>G\B83 B@B: >;GBE >9 8?;JH 9[[ >?B ;B8R9:8GVGAG>D C?G


11/360

VBE8GEB= #?G8 C78 7 H;7:> >9 8>JED d>?B ;9AB 9[ >?B %7;7E9^B8 9[ 'V8>;7G9: G:)9\\J:GG9:=e

5:EB; >?G8 H;7:>3 67D 17ABD3 69?: cB7]A7:E3 7:E FGAA -;D K9G:BE \B >9 [9;\ 78\7AA ;B8B7;


12/360

C?9 VBAGB@BE G: "RBG9:L cGAAG7\ FA7]B3 >?B R9B> 7:E R7G:>B;3 C?9 87Cd>?;9JH? ?G8 BDB83 :9> CG>? >?B\3e 7:E ]:BC \9;B 7V9J> C?7> G> G8 >9 VB ?J\7: >?7:7:D 9>?B; \7:L "7\JBA FJ>AB;3 >?B 7VAB8> B\R9;7;D G< 9[ 07;CG:G7: B@9AJ>G9:7:E >?B [G;8> 7:7AD8> 9[ 7 8


13/360

!"2 345'/16+53/4

;N3N; 0B# 2I@#,I# %L 8@,? ),? ."?#"O

#?B >G>AB 9[ >?G8 V99] 9[ B:EBE R;B9EB[G:B >?B B:>8= #?B B887D83 8R;B7E 9@B; >?G;>Da[G@B DB7;83 9 R;9R98B 7:BC C7D 9[ >?G:]G:H 7V9J> GEB78 7:E 7V9J> >?98B 7HH;BH7>B8 9[ GEB78 C?G


14/360

EB[G:B >?7> EG[[B;B:;J?7> 7:D 8>JEDC?G JR9: >?B :7>J;B 9[ d9;EB;e 9; dR7>>B;:e G: >?B J:G@B;8B G8 8J;BAD:9:>;G@G7A=

FJ> >?G8 7:8CB; 9:AD VBH8 >?B _JB8>G9:=

/ J8BE >9 >B78 >?7> 7;B G: >?B8B B887D8= #?BD C9JAE 7>>B:E EJ>G[JAAD 7:E B@B: CG>? G:>B:8BG:>B;B8> >9 C?7> / C78 87DG:H3 VJ> B@B;D DB7; >?B _JB8>G9: C9JAE 7;G8B 7[>B; >?;BB 9;[9J; 8B88G9:8 9[ >?B G8 >?G8 je

/ >;GBE @7;G9J8 7:8CB;8 >9 >?G8 _JB8>G9:= &: 9[ B


15/360

#?B EG7H;7\ ?7E >?;BB ?B AB[>3 / AG8>BE @7;G9J8 89;>8 9[J:G:>B;R;B>BE E7>73 8J


16/360

A78> >?BD 7;B C9;>?D 9[ 7 RA7?BAG8> 9[ [J:E7\B:>7A8= 'V9J> [G[>D DB7;8 9[ C9;] G: C?G


17/360

7V9J> \7: f C?9 EB[G:B BG>?B; B:>;9RD 9; 7 87 f?7E VB>>B; ?9AE ?G8RB7?B; >?7: 7EE >9 >?B B^G8>G:H KJ:HAB 9[ ?7A[aV7]BE ?DR9>?B8B8=

FJ> >?B HJA[ VB>CBB: >?B ?BJ;G8>G< 7:E >?B [J:E7\B:>7A G8 :9> 89ABAD EJB >9B\RG;G?B G:EJG@B ?7VG>3 :9; B@B: >9 >?B 8BEJG9:8 9[ _JG?B [7JA>D BEJG9:7A 8D8>B\ C?G


18/360

R?GA989R?G< >?9JH?>L 7G:AD >9 7 RB;G9E VB[9;B 8BAD RJ;8JBE VD R;9[B88G9:7A8 G: 8BR7;7>BEG8?B ;7A 9;GHG: \D>? 9[ 6JE7B9a)?;G8>G7: RB9RAB8= c?7>

7;B >?B [J:E7\B:>7A R?GA989R?G< 7:E 8G[G< R;9VAB\8 CG>? C?G


19/360

J:EB;8>7:E7VAB3 >?B;B[9;B3 >?7> 7 RB;G>D 8?9JAE ?7@B VBB: G:@9]BE >9RB;[9;\ >?G8 [J:G9: 9[ G:H 7: 9>?B;CG8B G\R;9V7VAB 9;EB;=

IYQ )A98BAD AG:]BE CG>? >?B 89;>G:H 7:E EG@GEG:H G8 >?B \D8>B;D 9[ 9VB [9AA9CBE A7>B; VD >?B B^>;79;EG:7;D ?J\7: 7


20/360

;7>?B; >?7: [9;\= FJ> \B:>7A R;9G7>G9:3 R7>>B;:3 7:E 89 9:3 7;B \7>>B;8 9[ [9;\ ;7>?B; >?7: 8JV8>7:?G: >?B V9ED 9[ [J:E7\B:>7A83 >?7> ?7A[ C?G


21/360

4 5)"* 67 8#*)9%$:#+

0$-/(/#/&(b ' \B>7A9HJB G8 7 G9: 7V9J> 89\B R;9VAB\7>G< 8JVKB=#?G8 G9: 8?9JAE VB 8J


22/360

,"! 789:;8? 0@A 1< 5@BCDE F89 BC : 7>GG;8HI

07JH?>B;b 07EED3 C?D E9 >?G:H8 HB> G: 7 \JEEABj-7>?B;b c?7> E9 D9J \B7:j #?G:H8j .JEEABj0b cBAA3 RB9RAB 8RB:E 7 A9> 9[ >G\B >GEDG:H >?G:H83 VJ> >?BD :B@B; 8BB\ >9 8RB:E

>G\B \JEEAG:H >?B\= #?G:H8 KJ8> 8BB\ >9 HB> G: 7 \JEEAB VD >?B\8BA@B8= ':E>?B: RB9RAB ?7@B >9 >GED >?B\ JR 7H7G:=

-b FJ> E9 D9J; >?G:H8 HB> G: 7 \JEEAB G[ D9J E9:l> >9J


23/360

0b (93 >?7> C9JAE :9> VB >GED=-b c?7> 7V9J> >?B 9>?B; B:E 9[ >?B 8?BA[3 ?B;Bj *G]B >?G8j0b (93 >?7>l8 :9> C?B;B G> VBA9:H83 7:E 7:D?9C G> C9JAE ?7@B >9 VB 8>;7GH?>3 :9> 7AA

?B C7D D9J RJ> G>=

-b &?fG: >?B ;GH?> RA7;7GH?>=0b ,B8=-b cBAA3 >?7> \B7:8 >?7> >?B;B 7;B 9:AD @B;D [BC RA7


24/360

0b FJ>3 07EEDs-b / >BAA D9J G>l8 9:AD G: >?B \9@GB8 >?7> D9J ?G:H8 7:E >?BD 8BB\ >9 >7]B 9:

\9;B 9;EB; 7:E 8B:8B >?7: >?BD ?7E VB[9;Bs0b FJ>3 07EEDs

-b c7G> >GAA /l@B [G:G8?BE >?G8 >G\Bs ':E >?BD \7]B G> A99] AG]B >?7> G: >?B \9@GB8 VDE9G:H >?B C?9AB >?G:H V7 >?B AB>>B;8 7AA G: 9;EB; >9 8RBAA0&('*0 7:E >?B: >?BD 8>7;> >?B ?B: >?BD 8>7;> 8?7]G:H >?B >7VAB=

0b &?3 07EEDf/ ]:BC >?7> 7:E / EGE 89 C7:> >9 >BAA D9J >?7>f7:E >?B: C?B: >?BD;J: >?B [GA\3 >?BD ;J: G> V7?7> G> A99]8 78 >?9JH? >?G:H8 ?7E?7RRB:BE [9;C7;E8= FJ> ;B7AAD >?B 8?7]G:H ?7RRB:BE V7;DG:H >9 >BAA D9J C?D G> G8 7 ;B789: [9; >?G:H8 >9 ?7RaRB:G: 7 7G: C7D G[ CB ?7> >?7> C7D ?78 \9;B C7D8 9[ ?7RRB:G:H >?7:89\B 9>?B; C7D=

0b 07EEDfE9:l> VBHG: >7A]G:H :9:8B:8B=-b /l\ :9> >7A]G:H :9:8B:8B= *B>l8 8>7;> 7H7G:= #?B;Bl8 9:AD 9:B C7D 9[ 8RBAAG:H

0&('*0= 'H;BBEj

0b ,B8=-b 'AA ;GH?>= ':E >?B;B 7;B \GAAG9:8 7:E \GAAG9:8 7:E \GAaAG9:8 9[ C7D8 9[ 8>B;G:H8G^ AB>>B;8 9: >?B >7VAB= 'H;BBEj

0b ,B8= / 8JRR98B 89= )7: 89\B 9[ >?B8B VB JR8GEB E9C:j-b ,B8fKJ8> G: >?B 89;> 9[ ?GHHABEDaRGHHABED \JEEAB >?BD CB;B G: G: >?B [GA\= FJ>

>?B;B ?7>3 >?B;Bj ':E 9:AD 9:B 0&('*0j

0b 'AA ;GH?>fDB8= FJ>3 07EED3 >?B 87\B AB>>B;8 \GH?> 8RBAA &*0 0'(=-b (B@B; \G:E= #?B \9@GB RB9RAB E9:l> C7:> >?B\ >9 8RBAA &*0 0'(= #?BD 9:AD

C7:> 0&('*0=0b c?D E9 >?BDj

-b 07\: >?B \9@GB RB9RAB=0b FJ> D9J \B:>G9:BE >?B\ [G;8>3 07EED=-b ,B8fVJ> >?7> C78 >9 >;D >9 >BAA D9J C?D >?G:H8 ?7RRB: >?7> C7D G: C?G= FJ> E9:l> 8>7;> 7:D \9;B ?7;B8 ;J::G:Hf9:B G8 _JG>B B:9JH?= ':D?9C3 /

7\ >G;BE 9[ 0&('*03 AB>l8 >7]B 7:9>?B; B^7\RAB= *B>l8 >7]B >988G:H RB::GB8=0b 07EEDj ';B D9J 8>GAA >7A]G:H 7V9J> >?B 87\B _JB8>G9: CB 8>7;>BE CG>?j dc?D E9

>?G:H8 HB> G: 7 \JEEABje

-b ,B8=


25/360

0b #?B:3 07EED3 G8 C?7> D9J 7;B >;DG:H >9 87D >;JB 7V9J> RB::GB83 7:E 7V9J>0&('*03 7:E 7V9J> 8JH7; 7:E 87:E3 7:E 7V9J> \D R7G:> V9^3 7:E 7V9J>RB::GB8j

-b ,B8f>?7>l8 ;GH?>=

0b &?f/ C78 KJ8> C9:EB;G:H3 >?7>l8 7AA=-b (9C3 AB>l8 8BB G[ / G> 87GE >?G8 >G\B= *B>l8 H9 V79 >?B 87:E 7:E >?B 8JH7;37:E AB>l8 8JRR98B >?7> 89\BV9ED 87D8 >?7> ?7@G:H >?B 87:E 7> >?B V9>>9\ G8 d>GEDe9; d9;EB;AD=e

0b 07EED3 E9B8 89\BV9ED ?7@B >9 87D 89\B>?G:H AG]B >?7> VB[9;B D9J 9>7A] 7V9J> ?9C >?G:H8 7;B H9G:H >9 HB> \G^BE JR C?B: D9J 8>G; >?B\j

-b ,B8f>?7>l8 KJ8> >?B R9G:>= #?BD 87D C?7> >?BD ?9RB CGAA ?7RRB: 7:E >?B: / >BAA>?B\ G> C9:l> ?7RRB: VB?B;B 7;B 89 \7:D 9>?B; >?G:H8 >?7> \GH?> ?7RRB:=':E / ]:9C >?7> G> G8 \9;B AG]BAD >?7> 9:B 9[ >?B \7:D >?G:H8 CGAA ?7RRB: 7:E :9>9:B 9[ >?B [BC=

0b 07EED3 D9Jl;B KJ8> 7: 9AE V99]\7]B;3 V7?B 9>?B; ?9;8B8 7H7G:8> >?B 9:B

?9;8B >?7> / C7:> >9 VB> 9:=-b #?7>l8 ;GH?>3 \D EB7;= / HB> >?B\ >9 VB> 9: C?7> >?BD ?B d>GEDe C7Df/ ]:9C

>?7> >?B;B 7;B G:[G:G>BAD \7:D \JEEABE C7D8f89 >?G:H8 CGAA 7AC7D8 H9 >9C7;E\JEEAB 7:E \G^BE:B88=

0b FJ> C?D EGE:l> D9J 87D >?7> 7> >?B VBHG::G:H3 07EEDj / 99E>?7> 7AA ;GH?>=

-b ,B83 / 8JRR98B 89= ':D?9C3 G>l8 :9C VBE>G\B=0b 07EED3 C?D E9 H;9C:JR8 ?7@B C7;83 G:8>B7E 9[ KJ8> [GH?>G:H >?B C7D


26/360

,", 789:;8? 0@A 1< )J8CK@L8CHI

07JH?>B;b 07EED3 C?D E9 -;B:


27/360

0b (9s /lE VB [;GH?>B:BE= /lE >?G:] / ?7E 87GE 89\B>?G:H >?7> ?J;> ?G8 [BBAG:H8 7:ERB;?7R8 ?B \GH?> VB ;B7AAD 7:H;D=

-b ,B8f7:E D9J \GH?> VB ;GH?>=

k k k0b 'AA ;GH?>f89 >?BD 8>9R C7@G:H >?BG; 7;\8 C?B: >?BD 8>7;> VBG:H 7:H;D=-b c7G> 7 \G:J>B= #?B _JB8>G9:3 7[>B; 7AA3 G8 C?7> E9B8 9:B -;B:3 89 >?BD >7A] 7V9J> V78BV7AA 7:EH7;EB:8= FJ> 7;B >?BD B^a89 D9J \B:>G9: \D [G8?G:Hf7 \7>>B; 7V9J> C?G


28/360

H99E CG8?B8= $@B: >9 E9 \9;B >?7: B^


29/360

':E 7AA >?B 8D:>7^ 7:E H;7\\7; 7:E 7AA >?7> 8>J[[ G8 :9:8B:8B= />l8 7AA V78BE 9:>?B GEB7 >?7> d\B;Be C9;E8 B^G8>f7:E >?B;B 7;B :9:B=

0b FJ>3 07EEDs-b / >BAA D9JfCB ?7@B >9 8>7;> 7AA 9@B; 7H7G: [;9\ >?B VBHG::G:H 7:E 788J\B >?7>

A7:HJ7HB G8 [G;8> 7:E [9;Ba\98> 7 8D8>B\ 9[ HB8>J;B8= ':G\7A8 7[>B; 7AA ?7@B 9:ADHB8>J;B8 7:E >9:B8 9[ @9GBE A7>B;= .J


30/360

,". 789:;8? *M9 F:L8E :CG N8BCD O8JBEI

07JH?>B;b 07EED3 7;B >?B8B G9:8 8B;G9J8j-7>?B;b )B;>7G:AD >?BD 7;B=0b #?BDl;B :9> 7 89;> 9[ H7\B >?7> D9J RA7D CG>? \Bj-b +9E [9;VGEs VJ> >?BD 7;B 7 89;> 9[ H7\B >?7> CB RA7D >9HB>?B;=0b #?B: >?BDl;B :9> 8B;G9J8p

k k k-b "JRR98B D9J >BAA \B C?7> D9J C9JAE J:EB;8>7:E VD >?B C9;E8 d8B;G9J8e 7:E 7

dH7\B=e

0b cBAAs G[ D9Jl

;Bs / E9:l> ]:9C=-b /[ / 7\ C?7>j0b / \B7:s >?B G9:8 7;B 8B;G9J8 [9; \B3 VJ> G[ D9J 7;B 9:AD RA7DG:H 7

H7\Bs-b ">B7ED :9C= *B>l8 A99] 7> C?7> G8 H99E 7:E C?7> G8 V7E 7V9J> dRA7DG:He 7:E

dH7\B8=e -G;8> 9[ 7AA3 / E9:l> \G:E f:9> \J 8R9>3 8J;B3 / >;D 7 AG>>AB ?7;EB; >9 >?G:] 8>;7GH?>7:E >9 87D / \B7:= FJ> / E9:l> VAJ[[ 7:E / E9:l> 8B> >;7R8= #?B;B G8 :9>B\R>7>G9: >9


31/360

0b FJ> G> E9B8:l> \7]B 8B:8B3 07EED= />l8 7: 7C[JA \JEEAB=-b ,B8f7 \JEEABfVJ> 8>GAA 7 89;> 9[ 8B:8B=0b 19C3 07EEDj

k k k-b c7G> 7 \G:J>B= #?G8 G8 EG[[G >9 87D= -G;8> 9[ 7AAf/ >?G:] >?7> CB HB> 89\BC?B;BCG>? >?B8B G9:8= / B:K9D >?B\ @B;D \J 7:E / >?G:] >?7> >?B\JEEAB8 ?BAR= / \B7:f>?7> G[ CB V9>? 8R9]B A9HG?B >G\B3 CB C9JAE:B@B; HB> 7:DC?B;B= cB C9JAE 9:AD R7;;9> 7AA >?B 9AE 8 9; >9 87D :BC >?G:H83 CB ?7@B >9 V;B7] JR 7AA9J; ;B7EDa\7EB GEB78 7:E 8?J[[AB >?B RGB3 07EED3 >?B R;G:>B; C9JAE :9> 8?J[[AB 7AA >?B AB>>B;8j c9JAE ?Bj 1B C9JAE:l>8?7]B >?B\ 7AA JR G: 7 V7H= 1B C9JAE RJ> >?B\ 9:B VD 9:B G: >?BG; RA7?B7l8 G: 9:B V9^ 7:E 7AA >?B Vl8 G: 7:9>?B;3 7:E 7AA >?B ?B;3 7:E 899:=

-b ,B8f>?7>l8 ;GH?>= &>?B;CG8B ?B C9JAE H9 \7E >;DG:H >9 [G:E 7: 7 C?B: ?B C7:>BEG>=

k k k-b c?7> 7;B D9J >?G:]G:Hj0b (9fG>l8 9:AD >?7> >?B;B 7;B 89 \7:D _JB8>G9:8= -b -9; B^7\RABj0b cBAA3 / 8BB C?7> D9J \B7: 7V9J> 9J; HB>>G:H G:>9 \JEEAB8= #?7> >?7> \7]B8 J8 87D

:BC 89;>8 9[ >?G:H8= FJ> / 7\ >?G:]G:H 7V9J> >?B R;G:>B;= 1B ?78 >9 ]BBR 7AA ?G8AG>>AB AB>>B;8 89;>BE 9J> B@B: >?9JH? ?B V;B7]8 JR 7AA >?B ;B7EDa\7EB R?;78B8=':E / 7\ C9:EB;G:Hl 7V9J> 9J; \JEEAB8= 09 CB ?7@B >9 ]BBR >?B AG>>AB RGB?9JH?> G: 89\B 89;> 9[ 9;EB;f>9 ]BBR [;9\ H9G:H \7Ej

-b / >?G:] 89fDB8fVJ> / E9:l> ]:9C C?7> 89;> 9[ 9;EB;= #?7> C9JAE VB 7 >B;;GVAD?7;E _JB8>G9: >9 7:8CB;= / E9:l> >?G:] CB 7: 7:8CB; >9 >?7> _JB8>G9:>9E7D=


32/360

k k k-b ,9J 87GE >?B;B CB;B d89 \7:D _JB8>G9:8=e 09 D9J ?7@B 7:9>?B;j0b ,B8f7V9J> H7\B8 7:E VBG:H 8B;G9J8= #?7>l8 C?7> CB 8>7;>BE [;9\3 7:E / E9:l>

]:9C ?9C 9; C?D >?7> ABE J8 >9 >7A] 7V9J> 9J; \JEEAB8= #?B C7D D9J ?G:HfG>l8 7 89;> 9[


33/360

0b FJ> D9J 87GE >?7> G[ CB 7AC7D8 >7A]BE A9HG HB> G:>9 \JEEAB83 CB?G:H :BC= cB ?G:H8= c?7> EGED9J ?98B >?G:H8j

-b )AG :9> HB> G:>9 >?B8B E;B7E[JA \JEEAB8=

-b ,B8= FJ> C7G>= ,9J \B7: >?7> / HB> J8 G:>9 >?B8B \JEEAB8 VB ?7@B ;JAB8 C?G= cB >9= FJ> 7> >?B \9\B:> /

C9JAE ;7>?B; RA7D >?G8 H7\B= &:AD / E9:l> ]:9C C?7> 89;> 9[ 7 H7\B >?G8 G8= (9;C?7> 89;> 9[ ;JAB8 G> ?78=

-b ':E DB> CB ?7@B VBB: RA7DG:H [9; 89\B >G\B=

0b ,B8= ':E G>l8 VBB: [J:=-b ,B8=

k k k-b *B>l8 H9 V79 >?B _JB8>G9: C?G


34/360

-b 1\\fDB8f7H7G:= / CG8? / G> G8:l> AG]B >?7>= /[ G> CB;B AG]B


35/360


36/360

-b FJ> DB8 / 99= /[ >?B >?G:H8 >9 VB \JA>GRAGBE 7;B RGB?G:H AG]B >?7>= FB?B\ G8 7 E9JVAB 89\B>?G:H=

0b / E9:l> J:EB;8>7:E=-b cBAAf7> AB78> 7 E9JVAB 89\B>?G:H=

0b 07EEDp-b ,B8f>7]B >?B H7\B 9[ #CB:>D vJB8>G9:8= ,9J >?G:] 9[ 89\B>?G:H= "7D D9J >?G:]9[ d>9\9;;9C=e 'AA ;GH?>= (9C / 78] d/8 G> 7V8>;7je 7:E D9J 87D d,B8=e(9C [;9\D9J; dDB8e / ?7@B H9> 7 E9JVAB VG> 9[ G:[9;\7>G9:= / ]:9C >?7> G> G8 7V8>;7 7:E /]:9C >?7> G> G8:l> >?G8 C7Df[;9\ D9J; dDB8e / ?B:J\VB; 9[ R988GVGAG>GB8 9[ C?7> >?B >?G:H E9C: >?B >9>7A R988GVGAG>GB8 >9 7: BGH?>? 9[ C?7> >?BD CB;B 7> >?B VBHG::G:H= ':E>C9 >G\B8 >C9 >G\B8 >C9 G8 BGH?>=

0b ':E >C9 7:E >C9 7:E >C9 G8 9:AD 8G^=-b #?7>l8 ;GH?>=0b FJ>3 07EED3 / E9:l> 8BBfC?7> ?7RRB:8 CG>? #CB:>D vJB8>G9:8j-b #?B R9G:> G8 >?7> G[ / RGG9:8 R;9RB;AD / C9 >G\B8

>C9 >G\B8 >C9 >G\B8 >C9 >CB:>D >G\B8 9@B; >?G:H8fTTW>?G:H8= #?7>l8 9@B; 7 \GAaAG9: >?G:H8 >?7> D9J \GH?> ?7@B >?9JH?> 9[= &:B _JB8>G9: G8 B:9JH? >9 EBCBB: >C9 >?G:H8L 7:E >C9 _JB8>G9:8 CGAA EBCBB: [9J; >?G:H8f7:E 899:=0b / E9:l> AG]B 7;G>?\B>G 9J> G8 EJAA3 VJ> 89\B 9[ >?B GEB78 G: G> 7;B 7\J8G:H=

':D?9C3 D9J C7:>BE >9 ]:9C ?9C >9 \B78J;B ]:9CABEHB3 7:E G[ D9J 8>7;>\B78J;G:H >?G:H8 >?7> 7AC7D8 AB7E8 >9 7;G>?\B>G \B78J;BE 7:D ]:9CABEHB DB>=-b (9= / ]:9C= FJ> CB ?7@B \7EB 7 8>BR 9; >C9 >9C7;E ]:9CG:H ?9C CB C9JAE

\B78J;B G> G[ CB C7:>BE >9= ':E >?7> \B7:8 CB 7;B 7 AG>>AB :B7;B; >9 ]:9CG:HC?7> ]:9CABEHB G8=

0b #?7> C9JAE VB 7 [J::D 89;> 9[ ]:9CABEHB3 07EED= / \B7: ]:9CG:H 7V9J>

]:9CABEHBfC9JAE CB \B78J;B >?7> 89;> 9[ ]:9CG:H >?B 87\B C7Dj-b c7G> 7 \G:J>Bf/ E9:l> ]:9Cf>?7>l8 ;B7AAD >?B wXZ vJB8>G9: 9: >?G8 8JVKB=

FBl8 H9 V79 >?B H7\B 9[ #CB:>D vJB8>G9:8= #?B R9G:> >?7> CB:B@B; \B:>G9:BE G8 >?7> >?98B _JB8>G9:8 ?7@B >9 VB G: 7 7G: 9;EB;= -G;8> >?BCGEB HB:B;7A _JB8>G9: 7:E >?B: >?B EB>7GABE _JB8>G9:= ':E G>l8 9:AD [;9\ 7:8CB;8>9 >?B CGEB _JB8>G9:8 >?7> / ]:9C C?G


37/360

-b &? DB8= &[>B:= FJ> / E9:l> _JG>B ]:9C C?7> >?B 7:8CB;8 \B7:>= #?BD E9 G> CG>?B^7\G:7>G9:8 7:E >B8>8 7:E _JG``B83 VJ> G>l8 AG]B >;DG:H >9 [G:E 9J> ?9C VGH 7 RGB?;9CG:H 8>9:B8 7> G>=

0b 19C E9 D9J \B7:j

-b / \B7:fG[ D9J >?;9C 8>9:B8 7> >C9 RGB?B 87\B EG8>7:?7> D9J ?G> 9:B RGBB: >?7: >?B 9>?B;3 >?B: R;9V7VAD >?B 9:B>?7> D9J ?G> \98> CGAA VB VGHHB; >?7: >?B 9>?B;= /: >?B 87\B C7D3 G: 7:B^7\G:7>G9: D9J >?;9C 7 A9> 9[ _JB8>G9:8 7> >?B 8>JEB:>83 7:E G[ D9J [G:E >?7> D9J?G> \9;B RGBJEB:> >?7: G: >?B 9>?B;83 >?B: D9J >?G:]>?7> 8>JEB:> \J8> ]:9C \9;B= #?7>l8 >?B GEB7=

0b FJ> C7Dj-b "J;BAD 9:B \GH?> B@B: VB _JG>B 7 H99E C7D 9[ E9G:H G>= cB E9 \B78J;B 7

A9> 9[ >?G:H8 >?7> C7D= -9; B^7\RAB3 CB KJEHB ?9C 8>;9:H 7 ?7> G83 CB A99] >9 8BB ?9C \J G8 8>9RRBE=cB >?;9C AGH?> C7@B8 7> G> G:8>B7E 9[ 8>9:B83 G>l8 >?B 87\B GEB7=

0b &?=

k k k0b FJ> >?B:fC?D 8?9JAE:l> CB \B78J;B ]:9CABEHB >?7> C7Dj-b 19Cj FD _JG``B8j (9f+9E [9;VGE= #?B >;9JVAB G8 >?7> >?7> 89;> 9[ \B78J;G:H

AB7@B8 9J> D9J; R9G:>f>?7> >?B;B 7;B EG[[B;B:> 89;>8 9[ ]:9CABEHBf7:E >?7>>?B;Bl8 ]:9CG:H 7V9J> ]:9CABEHB= ':E 9JH?> 9:B >9 HG@B ?GH?B; \7;]8 >9 >?B8>JEB:> C?9 ?B CGEB8> _JB8>G9:j &; RB;?7R8 >?B;B 8?9JAE VB 7EG[[B;B:> 89;> 9[ \7;]8 [9; B7= *B>l8 E9 >?7> 7:E >?B: 7EE >?B \7;]8 >9HB>?B; 7:E >?B:s

-b (9fCB 7EE >?B\ >9HB>?B;= cB \GH?> \JA>GRAD 9; EG@GEB 9:B 89;> 9[\7;]8 VD 7:9>?B; 89;> VJ> CB 7EE >?B\=

0b c?D :9>3 07EEDj-b FB?\B>G< G[ >?BD E9:l>

>BAA D9J >?7> 89;> 9[ >?G:H 7> 8


38/360

>9HB>?B; 7:E \JA>GRAD >?B ?9J;8 VD >?B \GAB8 7:E >?B: G> \JA>GRAGB8 >?B \GABa?9J;8 VD 89\B>?G:H BA8B C?G8 7> >?B 87\B >G\B= "9 / >?9JH?>d/>l8 8J\\B;e 7:E / >?9JH?> d/>l8 CG:>B;=e ':E >?B: / >;GBE >9 >?G:] >?B >C9>?9JH?>8 >9HB>?B;=

-b ,B8j0b FJ> / [9J:E / C78:l> ?7@G:H >C9 >?9JH?>8= / C78 9:AD ?7@G:H 9:B >?9JH?> 7V9J>

?7@G:H >C9 >?9JH?>8=-b "J;B3 >?7>l8 KJ8> G>= ,9J \G^ >?9JH?>83 D9J AD E9 >?7>=

0b #?B: ;B7AAD E9 CB 9:AD ?7@B 9:B VGH >?9JH?> C?G


39/360

,"T 789:;8? 0@A 1< 5@BCDE P:U8 />9;BC8EHI

07JH?>B;b 07EED3 C?D E9 >?G:H8 ?7@B 9J>AG:B8j-7>?B;b 09 >?BDj / E9:l> ]:9C= c?7> 89;> 9[ >?G:H8 E9 D9J \B7:j0b / \B7: C?B: / E;7C >?G:H83 C?D E9 >?BD ?7@B 9J>AG:B8j -b cBAA3 C?7> 7V9J> 9>?B;

89;>8 9[ >?G:H8f7 [A9?BD ?7@B 9J>AG:B8j0b 09:l> VB 8GAAD= / E;7C 7 G9:= / \B7: >?G:H8=-b ,B8f/ C78 >;DG:H >9 [G:E 9J> KJ8> C?7> D9J \B7:>= 09 D9J \B7: dc?D E9 CB HG@B

>?G:H8 9J>AG:B8 C?B: CB E;7C >?B\je 9; E9 D9J \B7: >?7> >?B >?G:H8 ?7@B 9J>aAG:B8 C?B>?B; CB E;7C >?B\ 9; :9>j

0b / E9:l> ]:9C3 07EED= ,9J >BAA \B= c?G


40/360


41/360

0b ':E R9; ?7@B R9; G: $:HA7:E3 07EEDj / EGE:l> ]:9C=-b &[ C78 G: $:HA7:E= ,9J E9:l> ?7@B EJ C7A] 7C7D 9[ G>8 9C: 7= "9 >?7> G>l8 7AA 89 \JEEABE >?7> :9V9ED BAA 7> 7AA C?7>l8 H9G:H >9

?7RRB:=0b ':E >?B ?99R8 C7A]BE 7;9J:E3 >993 VB?BD CB;B 89AEGB;8=-b #?7>l8 ;GH?>fB@B;D>?G:H C9JAE \9@B=0b 0GE B@B;D>?G:H ?7@B >9 VB 7AG@B 89 78 >9 \7]B 7 B \JEEABj-b (9f?B 7 \JEEAB VDs :93 / 8JRR98B D9Jl;B ;GH?>= #?7>l8

G:>B;B8>G:H= ,B83 G> ?7E >9 VB >?7> C7D= c7G> 7 \G:J>B= />l8 D9Jl;B ;GH?>=FB?G:H8 7:D 9>?B; C7D3 >?B RA7DB;8 9 EB7A CG>? >?B \JEEAG:H EB>7GA8= / \B7:3 8JRR98B >?B A7C: C78VJ\RD3 9; >?B V7AA8 CB;B 7 [J::D 8?7RB3 9; >?B ?B7E8 9[ >?B \7AAB>8 KJ8> C9VVADG:8>B7E 9[ VBG:H 7AG@B3 >?B: >?B RB9RAB GAA AB7;: 7:E >?B H7\B C9JAE 9:AD

VB \9;B EG[[GfG> C9JAE:l> VB G\R988GVAB= FJ> 9:?G:H8 G:>9G>3 G> VB ?7@B B^RBBE >?7>=0b c9JAE:l> D9J3 07EEDj / C9JAE ?7@B= #?7> 8BB\8 :7>J;7A >9 \B=-b (7>J;7Aj "J;Bf:7>J;7A B:9JH?= FJ> / C9JAE :9> ?7@B B^RBBE G> >9 C9;] >?7>

C7D=0b c?D :9>j #?7>l8 C?7> / C9JAE ?7@B B^RBBE=-b ,B8= FJ> >?G8 G8 >?B >?G:H >?7> / C9JAE :9> ?7@B B^RBBE= #?7> 7:G\7A83 C?G


42/360

0b c?7>j-b / E9:l> _JG>B ]:9Cf:9> DB>= "9\B>?G:H 7V9J> AG@G:H >?G:H8 7:E >?B EG[[B;B:CBB: >?B\ 7:E >?B >?G:H8 >?7> 7;B :9> 7AG@Bf\7


43/360

,"V 789:;8? 0@A : OQ:CHI

07JH?>B;b c?D 7 8C7:j-7>?B;b ,B8f7:E C?D 7 RJRRB> G: %B>;9J8?]7j0b (9f>?7>l8 EG[[B;B:>= '[>B; 7AA 7 RJRRB> G8 89;> 9[ ?J\7:f7:E >?7> R7;>G G8 @B;D ?J\7:= -b .9;B ?J\7: >?7: >?B RB9RABj0b ,B8=-b FJ> 8>GAA 9:AD 89;> 9[ ?J\7:j ':E 7[>B; 7AA >?B 8C7: G8 7A89 89;> 9[ ?J\7:=0b ,B8=

k k k0b FJ> C?7> 7V9J> >?B E7:?B 8>7HB38?B 8BB\8 G:?J\7: 9; G\RB;89:7AfRB;?7R8 8JRB;?J\7:= / E9:l> ]:9C=-b ,9J \B7:f>?7> C?GAB >?B 8C7: G8 9:AD $ '238 2< 8C7: 7:E ?78 :9 CBVVG:H VB>CBB:

?B; >9B83 >?B E7:


44/360

-b (9fKJ8> 7 89;> 9[ 7 89;>= &: >?B 9>?B; ?7:E3 G[ D9J 87D 9[ 7 \7: >?7> ?B G8 7 >;JB?B G:8JA> G9:=

0b FJ> C?B: 7 -;B:


45/360

@G8GVAB 8GH:8 9[ 89\B G:C7;E 7:E 8RG;G>J7A H;7 G: )7>?9AG?7> C9JAE \7]B >?B V7AAB> G:>9 7 \B;B \B>7R?9; 7:E :9> 7 87=

0b FJ> D9J 87GE >?7> [9; 89\B RB9RAB G> G8 7 87= ,9J \B7: [9; %;9>B8>7:>8j-b (93 :9= / \B7: >?7> G[ [9; 89\B RB9RAB >?B V;B7E 7:E CG:B 7;B 9:AD 7 \B>7R?9;3

C?GAB [9; 9>?B;8f)7>?9AG?B V;B7E 7:E CG:B 7;B 7 87L >?B:3 G[ >?B;BVB 89\B [9; C?9\ >?B V7AAB> G8 7 \B>7R?9;3 >?B;B \7D VB 9>?B;8 [9; C?9\ G> G8B\R?7>G?7: 7 \B>7R?9;fVJ> ;7>?B; 7 87=

0b /: >?B )7>?9AG< 8B:8Bj-b ,B8=

k k k-b / \B7: >?7> G[ CB VD >?B R;9R98G>G9: d>?B V;B7E

7:E CG:B G8 :9> o89;> 9[l >?B V9ED 7:E VA99EeL >?B: CB 8?9JAE ]:9C \9;B 7V9J>C?7> CB \B7: C?B: CB 87D BG>?B; >?7> >?B 8C7: G8 d89;> 9[e ?J\7: 9; >?7> >?BV7AAB> G8 7 87=

0b cBAAf?9C E9 D9J >BAA >?B EG[[B;B:jeFJ> G: 7:D >B;=

k k k0b 09 D9J \B7: >?7> 7:DV9ED C?9 ]:BC >?G8 8B C9JAE ?7@B G> G: >?BG; R9CB; >9

VB 7 H;B7> E7: R9B>j-b (93 :93 :9= /> G8:l> AG]B >?7> 7> 7AA= / \B7: [G;8> >?7> H;B7> 7;> 7:E ;BAGHG9: 7:E 7AA >?B

;B8> 9[ G> G8 7V9J> >?G8 8BL VJ> ]:9CG:H >?B 8B G: 7: 9;EG:7;D ?B ]:9CB; ;9A=

k k k


46/360

0b 07EED3 C?7> ?78 ?7RRB:BEj cB CB;B >;DG:H >9 [G:E 9J> C?7> d89;> 9[e \B7:8C?B: CB 87D >?7> >?B 8C7: G8 d89;> 9[e ?J\7:= / 87GE >?7> >?B;B \J8> VB >C98B:8B8 9[ d89;> 9[=e &:B G: >?B R?;78B d>?B 8C7: [GHJ;B G8 7 o89;> 9[l 8C7:3 7:E7:9>?B; G: >?B R?;78B d>?B 8C7: [GHJ;B G8 o89;> 9[l ?J\7:=e ':E :9C D9J 7;B

>7A]G:H 7V9J> \D8>B;G9J8 8B8 7:E ;9A=-b 'AA ;GH?>= /lAA 8>7;> 7H7G:= #?B 8C7: [GHJ;B G8 :9> 7 ;B7A 8C7: VJ> 7 R;B>B:E 8C7:= />G8 7A89 7 R;B>B:Ea:9> ?J\7: VBG:H= /> G8 7A89 d;B7AADe 7 D9J:H A7ED CB7;G:H 7C?G>B E;B88= ':E 7 ;B7A 8C7: C9JAE ;B8B\VAB 7 D9J:H A7ED G: 7G: C7D8=

0b FJ> C?G >9 ]BBR >?B\ 8BR7;7>B=-b ,B8= #?7> G8 C?7> >?B A9HG?B 8G8>8 >;D >9 E9= FJ> >?BD E9 :9> B

V7AAB>8 >?7> C7Df:9; 878=


47/360

,"% 789:;8? 0@:9 3E :C 3CE9BCK9HI

07JH?>B;b 07EED3 C?7> G8 7: G:8>G:j-7>?B;b ': G:8>G:3 \D EB7;3 G8 7 B^RA7:7>9;D R;G: C?7> E9B8 G> B^RA7G:j-b ':D>?G:Hf7A\98> 7:D>?G:H 7> 7AA= ':D>?G:H D9J C7:> G> >9 B^RA7G:=0b 09:l> VB 8GAAD= /> E9B8:l> B^RA7G: H;7@G>D=-b (9= FJ> >?7> G8 VB8 dG:8>G:e >9 B^RA7G: H;7@G>D= [ >?BD EGE3 G>

C9JAE B^RA7G: G>= cB ?7> >?B \99: ?78 7: G:8>G: C?98B8>;B:H>? @7;GB8 G:@B;8BAD 78 >?B 8_J7;B 9[ >?B EG8>7: >?7>l8 :9:8B:8B3 07EED=-b ,B83 8J;BAD= FJ> G> C78 D9J C?9 \B:>G9:BE dG:8>G:3e :9> /=0b 'AA ;GH?>fVJ> >?B: C?7> E9B8 B^RA7G: H;7@G>Dj-b (9>?G:H3 \D EB7;3 VBD G8 7: B^RA7:7>9;D R;G:?7> D9J J8B 9:B B^RA7:7>9;D R;G:9 B^RA7G: 7:9>?B;j(B@B;j

-b 1\\s ?7;EAD B@B;= #?7> G8 C?7> (BC>9: \B7:> C?B: ?B 87GE3 d?DR9>?B8B8 :9:[G:H9=e

0b ':E C?7> E9B8 >?7> \B7:j %AB78B=-b cBAA3 D9J ]:9C C?7> d?DR9>?B8B8e 7;B= ':D 8>7>B\B:> AG:]G:H >9HB>?B; >C9

EB8G@B 8>7>B\B:>8 G8 7: ?DR9>?B8G8= /[ D9J 87D >?7> >?B;B C78 7 [JAA \99: 9:

-BV;J7;D M8> 7:E 7:9>?B; 9: .7;


48/360

-b (B7;AD3 VJ> :9> _JG>B= ,9J 8BB3 7: ?DR9>?B8G8 >;GB8 >9 B^RA7G: 89\B R7;>G?G:H VJ> 7: B^RA7:7>9;D R;G:De 9; dG:8>G:ef;B7AADB^RA7G:8 :9>?G:H= />l8 7 89;> 9[ G9:7A 7H;BB\B:> VB>CBB: 8G8>8 >9 8>9R>;DG:H >9 B^RA7G: >?G:H8 7> 7 7G: R9G:>=

0b #?B: G8 >?7> C?7> (BC>9: \B7:>j /[ dH;7@G>De B^RA7G:8 :9>?G:H VJ> G8 9:AD 7 89;>9[ [JAA 8>9R 7> >?B B:E 9[ 7 AG:B 9[ B^RA7:7>G9:3 >?B: G:@B:>G:H H;7@G>D C78 :9> >?B87\B 78 G:@B:>G:H 7: ?DR9>?B8G83 7:E ?B [G:H9 7:D?DR9>?B8B8=

-b #?7>l8 ;GH?>= #?B;Bl8 :9 B^RA7:7>G9: 9[ 7: B^RA7:7>9;D R;G:l8 AG]B 7 VA7l8 7 VA7 VB EJB >9 G:8>G:=0b "BA[aR;B8B;@7>G@B G:8>G:j

-b / 8JRR98B 89=0b c?7> G8 7 8BA[3 07EEDj 09B8 7 E9H ]:9C G> ?78 7 8BA[j


49/360

-b / E9:l> ]:9C= FJ> G[ >?B E9H E9B8 ]:9C G> ?78 7 8BA[3 7:E G> CGHHAB8 G: 9;EB; >9R;B8B;@B >?7> 8BA[3 >?B: G>8 CGHHAG:H G8 ;7>G9:7A3 :9> G:8>G:G@B=

0b &?= #?B: 7 d8BA[aR;B8B;@7>G@B G:8>G:e G8 7 ;7EGG9:= -b cBAA3 G>l8 7 89;> 9[?7A[C7D ?9J8B 9: >?B ;97E >9 7:>?;9R9\9;R?G8\=

0b &?= #?7>l8 V7E=-b FJ> >?B E9H \GH?> ]:9C G> ?7E 7 8BA[ 7:E :9> ]:9C >?7> >?7> 8BA[ 8?9JAE VBR;B8B;@BE= /> C9JAE >?B: VB ;7>G9:7A >9 :9> CGHHAB= "9 G[ >?B E9H 8>GAA CGHHAB83 >?G8C9JAE VB G:8>G:G@B= FJ> G[ G> AB7;:BE >9 CGHHAB3 >?B: G> C9JAE :9> VB G:8>G:G@B=

0b &?=

0b c?7> C9JAE :9> VB G:8>G:G@B3 07EEDj #?B AB7;:G:H 9; >?B CGHHAG:Hj-b (9fKJ8> >?B CGHHAG:H=0b ':E >?B AB7;:G:H C9JAE VB G:8>G:G@Bj-b cBAAs DB8= 5:AB88 >?B E9H ?7E >9 AB7;: >9 AB7;:= 0 b &?=

0b FJ>3 07EED3 C?7> G8 G:8>G: 8JRR98BE >9 B^RA7G:j-b / ]BBR >;DG:H >9 7@9GE >?7> _JB8>G9:= ,9J 8BB3 G:8>G:8 CB;B G:@B:>BE VB[9;B

7:DV9ED ]:BC 7:D>?G:H 7V9J> HB:B>G 9[ \9EB;: HB:B>G ?B9;D= "9 G> G8E9JVAD EG[[G >9 >;7:8A7>B dG:8>G:e G:>9 \9EB;: >B;\8 7:E GEB78=

0b ,B83 H9 9:=-b cBAA3 D9J ]:9C >?7> G: >?B


50/360

0b 07EED3 G8 >?B 7:7>9\D 9[ >?B HB:B8 7:E


51/360

0b ':E 7;B >?BD C;9:Hj-b / E9:l> ]:9C= /> EBRB:E8 9: C?7> >?BD \B7:=0b &?=0b c?B: E9 >?BD E9 G>j

-b ,B83 >?7>l8 7 VB>>B; C7D 9[ 78]G:H >?B _JB8>G9:= #?BD E9 G> C?B: >?BD 8BB 7 J;BE9 89\B>?G:H3 7:E >?BD 7;B 8J;Bb [G;8>3 >?7> >?B J;B EGE :9> AB7;: ?9C >9 E9>?7> 89\B>?G:H 7:E3 8B?7> >?B J;B G8 >99 8>JRGE >9 J:EB;8>7:E C?D G>8?9JAE E9 >?7>=

0b ':D 9>?B; >G\Bj-b ,B8= c?B: >?BD 8BB >?7> 7AA \B\VB;8 9[ >?B 8RB?B 87\B >?G:H8 J:EB; >?B

87\B ?B 7:G\7A ;BRB7>G:H >?B 87\B 7G9:B@B: C?B: >?B


52/360

-b ,B8= #?7>l8 7 H99E _JB8>G9:3 7:E 8G8>8 ?7@B >7A]BE 7 H;B7> EB7A 7V9J> G>3 \7]G:HAG8>8 9[ 8BR7;7>B G:8>G:8 7:E >?B: AJ\RG:H >?B\ >9HB>?B; 7H7G:=

0b FJ> C?7>l8 >?B 7:8CB;j-b cBAA= />l8 :9> _JG>B 9:B >?G:H G8 7G:b #?7> B^RA7:7>9;D R;G: VB :9> \JA>GRAGBE VBD9:E :BD=0b ':E >?7> \B7:8j %AB78Bj-b />l8 >?B GEB7 VB?G:E \9:9>?BG8\f>?7> >?B GEB7 9[ 9:B VGH +9E G8 >9 VB R;B[B;;BE >9

>?B GEB7 9[ >C9 AG>>AB H9E8=0b /8 +9E 7: B^RA7:7>9;D R;G: J8B >C9 VA7C9 G:8>G:8f>9

B^RA7G: C?7> 9:B VA7 CB;B VGH B:9JH?=-b (9= /> \B7:8s0b ';B >?B;B VGH G:8>G:8 7:E AG>>AB G:8>G:8j-b cBAAf78 7 \7>>B; 9[ [73 8G8>8 E9 >7A] 78 G[ >?B;B CB;B= FJ> >?BD ?B AG>>AB

G:8>G:8 VD 9>?B; :7\B8 fe;B[AB^B83e dG::7>B ;BAB78G:H \B


53/360

0b )9JAE CB E9 CG>?9J> >?B GEB7 9[ dG:8>G:ej-b 19C C9JAE D9J B^RA7G: >?G:H8 >?B:j0b cBAA= /lE KJ8> A99] 7> >?B AG>>AB >?G:H8b c?B: 89\Ba>?G:H H9B8 dR9R3e >?B E9H

KJ\R8= c?B: >?B H;9J:E G8 :9> J:EB; ?G8 [BB>3 ?B CGHHAB8= ':E 89 9:=

-b ,9J \B7:f7AA >?B G\R8 VJ> :9 H9E8j0b ,B83 89\B>?G:H AG]B >?7>=-b cBAA= #?B;B 7;B 8G8>8 C?9 >;D >9 >7A] >?7> C7D3 7:E G>l8 VBB

[78?G9:7VAB= #?BD 87D G> G8 \9;B 9VKBG@B=0b ':E G8 G>j-b &?3 DB8=

0b c?7> E9B8 d9VKBG@Be \B7:j-b cBAA= /> \B7:8 >?7> D9J A99] @B;D ?7;E 7> >?98B >?G:H8 C?G= FJ> ?9C E9 >?B 9VKBG@B RB9RAB


54/360

0b /8:l> G> >;JB >?7> RB9RAB ?7@B 7 8RB VBG:H 9VKBG@B 7V9J> >?B\9;B 7:G\7A R7;>8 9[ >?BG; :7>J;Bj

-b / HJB88 89= ':D?9C -;BJE 87GE 893 7:E / >?G:] ?B C78 ;GH?>= c?D E9 D9J 78]j0b FB?98B R99; RB9RAB= #?BD >;D >9 8>JED 7:G\7A8= ':E >?BD

8RB?98B >?G:H8 >?7> >?BD JED 9VKBG@BAD= ':E >?BD >?98B >?G:H8 G: C?G


55/360

0b +9 9:=-b cBAA= /> 8AG?G:H >9 VG>8=0b / E9:l> J:EB;8>7:E=-b cBAA3 >?B [G;8> 8AGCBB: >?B 9VKBG@B >?G:H 7:E >?B ;B8>= ':E >?B: G:8GEB >?B

J;B >?7>l8 \7EB G: >?B \9EBA 9[ G:>BAAB3 A7:HJ7HB3 7:E >99A83 G> G8 :7>J;7A>?7> RJ;R98B CGAA B@9A@B= #99A8 7;B [9; RJ;R98B8 7:E 7:D>?G:H C?G=0b "93 G:B@G>7VAD3 C?B: >?B 9VKBG@B J;B A99]8 7> 7:G\7A83 G> 8RAG>8 >?G:H8 JR 7:E

\7]B8 >?B 7:G\7A8 A99] AG]B ?J\7: VBG:H8 7[>B; >?BG; G:>BAAB8 ?7@B G:@7EBE>?BG; 89JA8=

-b $^7AD= />l8 7 89;> 9[ G:?J\7: 7:>?;9R9\9;R?G8\=0b ':E >?7> G8 C?D >?B 9VKBG@B RB9RAB 8>JED 7AA >?B AG>>AB G\R8 G:8>B7E 9[ >?B A7;HB;

>?G:H8j-b ,B8= />l8


56/360

-b / E9:l> ]:9C C?B;B >9 VBHG:=0b cBAA= 09 E;B7\8 H9 VD 9RR98G>B8j-b &? *9;Ep #?B 9AE [9A] GEB7= (9= #?BD E9:l> R;BEG >?B [J>J;B= 0;B7\8 7;B 89;> 9[

8J8RB:EBE G: >G\B= #?BD E9:l> ?7@B 7:D >B:8B8=

0b FJ> G[ 7 RB;89: G8 7[;7GE 9[ 89\B>?G:H C?G E;B7\ 7V9J> G> >9a:GH?>j-b )B;>7G:AD= &; 7V9J> 89\B>?G:H G: ?G8 R78>= &; 7V9J> V9>? R78> 7:E R;B8B:>= FJ>

>?B E;B7\ 7G:8 :9 A7VBA >9 >BAA ?G\ C?7> G> G8 d7V9J>e G: >?G8 8B:8B= /> KJ8> G8=0b 09 D9J \B7: G>l8 78 G[ >?B E;B7\ ?7E :9 >G>AB R7HBj-b ,B8= />l8 AG]B 7: 9AE \7:J8 9; 7 AB>>B; >?7> ?78 A98> G>8 VBHG::G:H 7:E B:E3 7:E

>?B ?G8>9;G7: ?78 >9 HJB88 C?7> G>l8 7AA 7V9J> 7:E C?9 C;9>B G> 7:E C?B:f[;9\C?7>l8 G:8GEB G>=

0b #?B: CBl;B H9G:H >9 ?7@B >9 VB 9VKBG@B3 >99j-b ,B8 G:EBBE= FJ> CB ]:9C >?7> CB ?7@B >9 VB G>= cB ?7@B >9 C7>= ,B8= 0;B7\8 7;B G: \7:D C7D8 AG]B \D>?8 7:E [7VAB8= FJ> :9> RA7::BE=0b 09B8 7 E;B7\ 7AC7D8 ?7@B 7 \9;7Aj-b / E9:l> ]:9C 7V9J> 7AC7D8= FJ> 9[>B:3 DB8= FJ> >?B \9;7A G8 :9> 8>7>BE G: >?B E;B7\=

#?B R8D= ' [;GB:E 9[ \G:B C78 7 [GH?>B; RGA9> G: c9;AE c7; //= '[>B; >?B C7; ?B

VB VB[9;B >?B B^7\3 ?B ?7E 7 :GH?>\7;B G: C?G


57/360

0b FJ> ?9C EGE ?B ]:9C >?7>j #?B E;B7\ BAAG:H ?G\ >?7> >?BR;9[B889;8 C9JAE 8?99> ?G\ E9C:= 19C EGE ?B ]:9C G> C78 G;9:G ]:9C= #?B E;B7\ E9B8:l> ?7@B 7 A7VBA 9: G> >9 87D G>G8 G;9:G ?7@B A7:HJ7HB= />l8 RB;?7R8 R7;> 9[ >?B C;9:H 89;>9[ 9VKBG@G>D=

0b 'AA ;GH?>= #?B: E9 7:G\7A8 EB7A G: 9RR98G>B8j-b cBAA3 DB8= '8 7 \7>>B; 9[ [73 >?BD E9= FJ> /l\ :9> 8J;B G>l8 >?B 87\B >?G:Hs0b +9 9:= 19C E9 >?BDj ':E C?B:j-b cBAA= ,9J ]:9C ?9C 7 RJRRD AGB8 9: ?G8 V78 ?G8 VBAAD >9 7 VGHHB;

E9H= #?7>l8 89;> 9[ G:@G>G:H >?B VGHHB; E9H >9 7>>7 G> C9;]8 G: >?B 9RR98G>BC7D= /> 8>9R8 >?B VGHHB; E9H [;9\ 7>>7 G8 7 89;> 9[ J8B 9[ 9RR98G>B8= FJ> E9 >?BD ]:9C >?7>j-b ,9J \B7: E9B8 >?B VGH E9H ]:9C >?7> >?B AG>>AB E9H G8 87DG:H >?B 9RR98G>B 9[ C?7>

?B \B7:8j ':E E9B8 >?B AG>>AB E9H ]:9C >?7> >?7> G8 >?B C7D >9 8>9R >?B VGH E9Hj0b ,B8=-b / E9:l> ]:9C= / 89\B>G\B8 >?G:] >?B AG>>AB E9H ]:9C8 7 AG>>AB \9;B 7V9J> G> >?7:

>?B VGH E9H= ':D?9C3 >?B AG>>AB E9H E9B8 :9> HG@B 7:D 8GH:7A8 >9 8?9C >?7> ?B]:9C8= 1B 9V@G9J8AD E9 >?7>=

0b #?B: G>l8 AG]B >?B E;B7\8= #?B;Bl8 :9 A7VBA >9 87D >?7> >?B E;B7\ G8 EB7AG:H G:

9RR98G>B8=-b #?7>l8 ;GH?>=0b / >?G:] CBl;B HB>>G:H 89\BC?B;B= 0;B7\8 EB7A G: 9RR98G>B83 7:E 7:G\7A8 EB7A G:

9RR98G>B83 7:E :BG>?B; 9 87D C?B: >?BD 7;B EB7AG:H G: 9RR98G>B8=-b 1\\=

0b c?D E9 7:G\7A8 [GH?>j-b &?3 [9; \7:D ;B789:8= #B;;G>9;D3 8B^3 [99Es0b 07EED3 D9Jl;B >7A]G:H AG]B G:8>G: >?B9;D= / >?9JH?> CB 7H;BBE :9> >9 E9 >?7>=-b 'AA ;GH?>= FJ> C?7> 89;> 9[ 7: 7:8CB; E9 D9J C7:> >9 >?B _JB8>G9:3 C?D 7:G\7A8

[GH?>j

0b cBAA= 09 >?BD EB7A G: 9RR98G>B8j-b &?= ,B8= ' A9> 9[ [GH?>G:H B:E8 JR G: 89\B 89;> 9[ RB7


58/360

-b / E9:l> ]:9C 7V9J> 7AC7D8= FJ> 9[>B:3 DB8= FJ> >?B \9;7A G8 :9> 8>7>BE G: >?B E;B7\=#?B R8D= ' [;GB:E 9[ \G:B C78 7 [GH?>B; RGA9> G: c9;AE c7; //= '[>B; >?B C7; ?B

VB VB[9;B >?B B^7\3 ?B ?7E 7 :GH?>\7;B G: C?G


59/360

0b / >?G:] CBl;B HB>>G:H 89\BC?B;B= 0;B7\8 EB7A G: 9RR98G>B83 7:E 7:G\7A8 EB7A G:9RR98G>B83 7:E :BG>?B; 9 87D C?B: >?BD 7;B EB7AG:H G: 9RR98G>B8=

-b 1\\=

0b c?D E9 7:G\7A8 [GH?>j-b &?3 [9; \7:D ;B789:8= #B;;G>9;D3 8B^3 [99Es0b 07EED3 D9Jl;B >7A]G:H AG]B G:8>G: >?B9;D= / >?9JH?> CB 7H;BBE :9> >9 E9 >?7>=-b 'AA ;GH?>= FJ> C?7> 89;> 9[ 7: 7:8CB; E9 D9J C7:> >9 >?B _JB8>G9:3 C?D 7:G\7A8

[GH?>j0b cBAA= 09 >?BD EB7A G: 9RR98G>B8j-b &?= ,B8= ' A9> 9[ [GH?>G:H B:E8 JR G: 89\B 89;> 9[ RB7 >?B:=0b *B>l8 H9 V79 >?7> E;B7\= />8 >9>7A B[[B 9: >?B \7: C78 >?B 87\B 78 G[

89\BV9ED ?7E 87GE >9 ?G\3 d oD9J G: 7 [GH?>B; RA7:Bl G8 :9> B_J7A >9 oD9J G: 7:9;7A B^7\=l d

-b ,B8= FJ> >?B E;B7\ EGE:l> 8RBAA >?7> 9J>= /> 9:AD 87D83 dD9J G: 7 [GH?>B; RA7:B= />AB7@B8 9J> >?B d:9>3e 7:E G> AB7@B8 9J> >?B G:8>;JG9: >9 ?B E;B7\ CG>?

89\B>?G:H BA8B 7:E G> E9B8:l> 87D C?7> ?B 8?9JAE CG>?=0b 'AA ;GH?>= *B>l8 >7]B >?B d:9>e [G;8>= /8 >?B;B 7:D d:9>e G: 7:G\7A VB?7@G9;j-b 19C ?B;B VBj0b / \B7: 8 7G9:83 d/ CGAA :9> VG>B D9Jej-b cBAA3 >9 VBHG: CG>?= )9\\J:GG9: VD 7G9:8 R988GVAD ?7@B >B:8B8= #?BD

7;B 9:AD R988GVAB G: A7:HJ7HB=0b 0GE:l> D9J 87D >?7> E;B7\8 ?7@B :9 >B:8B8j-b 1\\= ,B83 / EGE=0b &]7D= FJ> C?7> 7V9J> d:9>e= )7: >?B 7:G\7A 87D3 d/ 7\ :9> VG>G:H D9Jej-b #?7> 8>GAA ?78 7 >B:8B G: G>= FJ> :B@B; \G:E= /[ >?B 7:G\7A G8 :9> VG>G:H >?B 9>?B;3 ?Bl8

:9> VG>G:H G>3 7:E >?7>l8 G>=

0b FJ> ?B \GH?> VB :9> E9G:H 7AA 89;>8 9[ 9>?B; >?G:H83 8ABBRG:H3 B7>G:H3 ;J::G:H3 7:E89 9:= 19C l8 VG>G:H >?7> /l\ :9> E9G:Hej

-b 1B ?7> G[ VG>G:H ?78 89\B?9C VBB: \B:>G9:BE=0b 09 D9J \B7: >?7> ?B VG>G:H D9Je VD [G;8> 8?9CG:H ?G8 [7:H8

7:E >?B: :9> VG>G:Hj-b ,B8= "9\B>?G:H AG]B >?7>=0b FJ> C?7> 7V9J> >C9 7:G\7A8j #?BDlE V9>? ?7@B >9 8?9C >?BG; [7:H8=-b ,B8=0b ':E3 G> 8BB\8 >9 \B3 >?BD \GH?> \G8J:EB;8>7:E B7=-b ,B8= #?B;B G8 7AC7D8 >?7> E7:HB; C?B: D9J EB7A G: 9RR98G>B8 7:E E9 :9> 9;

87D C?7> D9J 7;B E9G:H3 B8RB ]:9C C?7> D9J 7;B


60/360

E9G:H= 0b FJ> >?B 7:G\7A8 C9JAE ]:9C >?7> >?BD V7;BE >?BG; [7:H8 G: 9;EB; >9 87D3d/ C9:l> VG>B D9J=e

-b / E9JV> C?B>?B; >?BD C9JAE ]:9C= )B;>7G:AD :BG>?B; 7:G\7A ]:9C8 G> 7V9J> >?B9>?B;= #?B E;B7\B; E9B8:l> ]:9C 7> >?B VBHG::G:H 9[ >?B E;B7\ ?9C >?B E;B7\ G8

H9G:H >9 B:E=0b #?B: G>l8 7 89;> 9[ B^RB;G\B:>s=-b ,B8=0b "9 >?BD \GH?> HB> G:>9 7 [GH?> G: 9;EB; >9 [G:E 9J> C?B>?B; [GH?>G:H C78 C?7> >?BD

?7E >9 E9=-b ,B8fVJ> /lE ;7>?B; RJ> G> AB88 RJ;R98G@BADf>?7> >?B [GH?> 8?9C8 >?B\ C?7> 89;> 9[

;BA7>G9:8?GR >?BD ?7@B3 7[>B; G>= />l8 :9> RA7::BE=0b #?B: d:9>e G8 ;B7AAD :9> >?B;B C?B: >?B 7:G\7A8 8?9C >?BG; [7:H8j-b / HJB88 :9>= &; 9[>B: :9>= %B;?7R8 9AE [;GB:E8 \GH?> B:H7HB G: RA7D[JA [GH?>G:H 7:E

]:9C 7> >?B VBHG::G:H C?7> >?BD 7;B E9G:H=

0b 'AA ;GH?>= #?B: >?B d:9>e G8 7V8B:> G: 7:G\7A VB?7@G9; VBe G8 R7;> 9[@B;V7A A7:HJ7HB3 7:E >?B;B VB 7:D 7G9: 8GH:7A [9;3d:9>=e ':E VB?B;B G8 :9 d:9>3e >?B 9:AD C7D >9 7H;BB 9: 7 :BH7>G@B G8 >9 7 9J> >?B C?9AB;BEJG9 7E 7V8J;EJ\= ,9J ?7@B >9 7 9J> >?B V7>>AB >9 R;9@B G> G8:l> 9:B3 7:E>?B: D9J ?7@B >9 7 9J> >?B 8JV\G88G9: >9 R;9@B >?7> >?B 9>?B; C9:l> B7> D9J=

-b ,B8=0b 0GE >?B 7:G\7A8 ?7@B >9 >?G:] >?7> 9J>j-b (9= FBl8 7AA :B;JB= ':E >?7> C?G


61/360

-b 'RR;9^G\7>BAD3 DB8= c?B: 7 \B>7R?9; G8 A7VBABE 78 7 \B>7R?9; G> VB7R?9; ?G:H8 CG>?9J> 8RBAAG:H 9J> >?B

>7]B8 C?7> G8 >;JB 9[ 9:B H;9JR 9[ >?G:H8 7:E 7RRAGB8 G> >9 7:9>?B;= c?B: CB 87D 7:7>G9: dEB7R?9;3 8JHHB8>G:H >?7> 89\B =e #?7> C9;E >?B C;G>B; G8 J8G:H AG>B;7AAD3 7:E

>?7> 9:B C9;E >BAA8 D9J C?7> 7AA >?B ;B8> G8 7V9J>=0b ':E G: 7 E;B7\j-b #?7> C9;E3 >993 C9JAE ?7@B VBB: \B>7R?9;G?B C?9AB R9B\ C9JAE ?7@B

VBB: \J= FJ> D9J 8BB C?7> / \B7: VD 87DG:H >?7> G: E;B7\8 >?B \B>7R?9;8 7;B :9>

RBHHBE E9C:=

0b 09 7:G\7A8 RBH E9C: >?BG; \B>7R?9;8j

-b (9= #?BD E9:l> ?7@B >9= ,9J 8BB3 C?B: 7 H;9C:aJR VG;E \7]B8 AG]B 7 V7VD VG;E G:7RR;97


62/360

0b cBl@B [9J:E 7 C?9AB A9> 9[ >?G:H8 G: CBB: E;B7\8 7:E 7:G\7AVB?7@G9;= #?BD V9>? EB7A G: 9RR98G>B83 7:E >?BD V9>? ?7@B :9 >B:8B83 7:E >?BDV9>? ?7@B :9 d:9>3e 7:E >?BD V9>? C9;] VD \B>7R?9;3 7:E :BG>?B; 9[ >?B\ RBH8>?B \B>7R?9;8 E9C:= FJ> C?7> / E9:l> J:EB;8>7:E G8fC?D3 C?B: >?B 7:G\7A8 E9

>?B8B >?G:H83 G> \7]B8 8B:8B= / \B7: [9; >?B\ >9 C9;] G: 9RR98G>B8= ':E >?BDE9:l> ?7@B >9 RBH E9C: >?BG; \B>7R?9;8fVJ> / E9:l> 8BB C?D E;B7\8 8?9JAE VBAG]B >?7>3 >99=

-b (9; E9 /=0b ':E >?B;Bl8 7:9>?B; >?G:H=-b ,B8j0b ,9J >7A]BE 7V9J> HB:B8 7:E


63/360

< 5)"* 667 =%"> ),? 5)**#", @,

A,*B"%C%9%$&


64/360

."! +>;9>J8 +B: VD 7 )9\\G>>BB 9[ >?B "9


65/360

:9:?7> B\R> >9 EB[G:B 7 dDRB=e

IYQ #?B .B\9;7:EJ\ G8 V78BE JR9: 7 [7AA7?7> CB ;7G>8 9[ 7J;B J:EB; 8J


66/360

cG>? >?G8 R;B7\VAB3 CB \7D :9C B;:7>G@B 8


67/360

G:EG@GEJ7A8 G: 7AA 9>?B; B^>8= 1B;B CB \J8> VB R;BR7;BE >9 [G:E >?7> >?B G:?B;B:>A9HG< 9[ 9:B J;B EG[[B;8 R;9[9J:EAD [;9\ >?7> 9[ 9>?B;8= -;9\ >?G8 R9G:> 9[ @GBC CB8?7AA 8BB3 [9; B^7\RAB3 >?7> C?B: G:EG@GEJ7A ' HG@B8 7 E;G:] >9 G:EG@GEJ7A F3 >?7>VB?7@G9; G8 B:> CG>? 9>?B; :9;\8 9[ VB?7@G9; 9V>7G:G:H CG>?G: >?B H;9JR

C?G


68/360

;BA7>G9:8?GR8 9V>7G:G:H VB>CBB: H;9JR8 9[ G:EG@GEJ7A8 CG>? EG[[B;B:>G7>BE VB?7@G9;R7>>B;:83 7:E A7>B; >9 AGH?> >?B8B ;BA7>G9:8?GR8 >?;9C JR9: C?7> 7;B\9;B J8J7AAD ?;9R9A9HG8> C?9 ?78 VBB: G: >?B [GBAE ?78?7E 9RR9;>J:G>D 9[ 8>JEDG:H 8J


69/360

IMUQ D65(+325(8& #?9JH? ;BA7>G9:8?GR8 VB>CBB: H;9JR8 C9 BH9;GB83 8D\\B>;G?G8 8JVEG@G8G9: G8 >9 89\BB^>B:> VAJ;;BE VD 7:9>?B; >DRB 9[ EG[[B;B:>G7>G9: C?G


70/360


71/360

?GB;7; VB


72/360

.", (WX8JBL8C9E BC 5@BCYBCD :M9 /ME8JU8G(9@C


73/360

C?B: / C78 7:7AD`G:H >?B R7>a>B;:8 9[ R7;>;GEHB8l [B7>?B;83 / \GH?> ;B7AAD HB> 7:7:8CB; 9; 7 VG> 9[ 7: 7:8CB; >9 >?B C?9AB RJ``AG:H VJ8G:B88 9[ R7>>B;: 7:E ;BHJA7;G>DG: :7>J;B= ':E [J;>?B;3 >?G8 VG> 9[ \D8>G7:> VB H7@B \B[;BBE9\ >9 J8B \D 8G[G< V7?B C7D8 9[ >?9JH?> >?7> / ?7E RG7;D R?D8G >9 [G> G: CG>? @B;D EG[[B;B:> [GBAE8 9[ 9V8B;@7>G9:= /> B:7VABE \B >9;BH7;E 7AA \D >;7G:G:H 78 R9>B:>G7AAD J8B[JA ;7>?B; >?7: J>>B;AD G;;BAB@7:> >97:>?;9R9A9HD=

c?B: / 9 7:>?;9R9A9HD >?B;B C78 7 7]G:H RA7 >?B J8B 9[ A998B 7:7A9HGB83 B8RB >?B "RB:CBB:>?B &;H7:G8\ 7:E "9D= #?7:]8 >9 >?G8 \D8>G?B RB;@7EG:H J:G>D 9[ >?BR?B:9\B:7 9[ >?B C9;AE3 / 7@9GEBE 7 H;B7> EB7A 9[ G:>BAABJ7A C78>B= / :B@B; ?7E 7:DE9JV> >?7> >?G8 7:7A9HD C78 [J:E7\B:>7AAD 89J:EL 8G:9 E9JV> C9JAE ?7@B VBB:B\9>G9:7AAD B^RB:8G@B= (9C7E7D83 9[ ?B B\R?78G8 ?78 8?G[>BE= -BC C9JAE8B;G9J8AD E9JV> >?7> >?B C7D8 9[ 7:7AD8G8 C?G 9; B^R98G>G9:L C?B:aB@B; CB8>7;> G:8G8>G:H >99 ?7;E JR9: d9RB;7>G9:7AG8\e 9; 8D\V9AG< A9HG< 9; 7:D 9>?B; 9[ >?B8B@B;D B88B:>G7A 8D8>B\8 9[ >;7\AG:B83 CB A98B 89\B>?G:H 9[ >?B 7VGAG>D >9 >?G:] :BC>?9JH?>8= ':E B_J7AAD3 9[ >?B 8>B;GAB ;GHGEG>D 9[[9;\7A >?9JH?> 7:E B^R98G>G9: 7:E AB> 9J; GEB78 ;J: CGAE3 CB AG]BCG8B A98B= '8 / 8BBG>3 >?B 7E@7:?9JH?> ?G8 G9: G8 >?B \98> R;B99A 9[ 8 9[ \G:EfG> ABE \B G:>9 CGAE d?J: 7:E >?B:G\\BEG7>BAD G:8G8>BE >?7> >?7> A998B:B88 VB \B78J;BE JR 7H7G:8> 7 ;GHGE G8 >?7> >?B [G;8> ?J: JR 7H7G:8> >?B ;GHGE [9;\JA7>G9:8 C?G


74/360

>?B: >?B EB[GAB; C9JAE VB RJ:G8?BE= 1G8 9C: H;7EB C9JAE EB[B:E ?G\ VJ> >?B 9>?B;8C9JAE 8>7;> 7 V;7CA=X

/ >?B: VBH7: A99]G:H [9; \9;B


75/360


76/360

,9J CGAA ?7@B :9>G?7> >?B [9;\ G: C?G >7A] 9[ 7^G7A H;7EGB:>83 / >7A]BE 7V9J> d78D\\B>;GG9:8?GR8 VB>CBB: 8J9

7>>7


77/360

"9 [7; 78 / C78 ?9JH?> 9[ G>\D8BA[= / [BA> >?7> / ?7E EG89 >?G:]= #?7> C78 G: MNTX3 7:E >?G8 87\B 9AE?7> /?7E 7 ;B C78 :9> J:>GA >B: DB7;8 A7>B; >?7> / [JAAD H;78RBE >?B 8GH:G[G CGAA VB 9[ G:>B;B8> >9 ;B G: 89\B EB>7GA \D @7;G9J8 V;J8?B8 CG>?>?B8B ?B ;B


78/360

[9;C7;E 89\B>?G:H AG]B dB>?9:9\D3e C?G


79/360

>?B d8>J[[e 9[ J;B3 9; dVG>8e 9[ J;B3 9; >?B d[BBAe 9[ J;B= #?B8B V;GB[ ':HA9a"7^9: >B;\8 ?7@B [9; \B 7 EB[G:G>B [BBAG:H >9:B C?G8 7;B A998B=

FJ> >?B8B 8G\GAB8 7V9J> B>?98 VBG:H >?B ;G@B; 7:E >?B [9;\JA7>G9:8 9[ J;B 9;dJ;7A 8>;JJ;Be VBG:H G>8 V7:]8 CB;B :9> ':HA9a"7^9: ;B\G:EB;8 >?7> / C78AB7@G:H 89\Ba>?G:H [9; 7:7AD8G8 7> 7 A7>B; E7>B= #?BD CB;B3 78 / >?9JH?>3 >?B ;B7A>?G:Hf7 ;B7A ;GVJ>G9: >9 9J; J:EB;8>7:EG:H 9[ ?9C J;B C9;]8= / >?9JH?> >?7>>?B;B C78 9:B 89;> 9[ R?B:9\B:9: C?GB;L 7 8>;JJ;7A VG>= #?B: / E;BC 7 A7>>G? >?;BB 8_J7;B8 G:B7


80/360

d#?G8 B^RB;G\B:> \7D 8BB\ RJB;GAB3 VJ> >9 \B G> C78 @B;D G\R9;>7:>3 7:E / ?7@B;BBE G> 7> AB:H>? VB?B;B \7D VB 89\B 7\9:H \D ;B7EB;8 C?9 >B:E >9;BH7;E 8JB:BE 9J>fVJ> / C78 7A89 C9;;GBE VB?9JH?> / 8?9JAE VB 9 ;BC;G>B >?B C?9AB V99]= FJ> / [9J:E >?7> >?G8 C78:9> 89= / ?7E >9 >J:B JR >?B EB[G:G>G9:83 VB >7]B: 78 7 C7;:G:H 9[ ?9C :9> >9 87D >?G:H8f7:E 89 9:= FJ> >?B V9ED 9[ >?B

V99] C78 89J:E B:9JH?f7AA >?7> G> :BBEBE C78 :BC 9;8 9: G>8 ABH8="9 [7; / ?7@B 8R9]B: 9[ \D 9C: RB;89:7A B^RB;GB:? 8>;G 7:E A998B

>?G:]G:H3 VJ> / >?G:] 7J7AAD >?B 8>9;D C?G >9 7
?G8 EJ7A :7>J;B 9[ 8G[G< >?9JH?> 7:E VB CGAAG:H >9@7AJB >?B C7D G: C?G :9> >9 [;9C: >99 \J G8 7RRAGBE >9 G>f7:E

:9C C?B: G:@B8>GH7>9;8 8>7;> ;BR?;78G:H >?B -;BJEG7: E9H\78 G: :BC 8>;GB; >B;\8>?B;B \7D VB 7 A9> 9[ GAA [BBAG:H3 C?GB:BE 9J>3 7:7AD8>8 CGAA VB 7VAB >9 B\V7;] JR9: 7 :BC 7:E 8>GAA

7*9


81/360

\9;B [;JG>[JA 9;HD 9[ A998B >?G:]G:H3 J:>GA >?BD ;B7 >9B:K9D >?G8 7A>B;:7>G:H _J7AG>D G: >?B R;9H;B88 9[ 8?B R;9H;B88 9[8?B; >?7: >?G83 VB8GEB8 8G\RAD :9> ?G:EB;G:H R;9H;B883 / >?G:] CB \GH?> E989\B>?G:H >9 ?78>B: \7>>B;83 7:E / ?7@B 8JHHB8>BE >C9 C7D8 G: C?G VBE9:B= &:B G8 >9 >;7G: 8G8>8 >9 A99] 7\9:H >?B 9AEB; 8?BG; 9C: \7>B;G7A3 89 >?7> >?BG; CGAE ?J:


82/360

.". 7


83/360

9[ 7:D \7\\7A3 7:E B8RB?B R;B@G9J8 B^RB;GB:?7> G:EG@GEJ7A= #?J8 G: R;B8J\G:H >?7>


84/360

9J> 89\B 89;> 9[ \J>J7A ;BAB@7:CBB: >?B 8RB


85/360

;B7G9:8 >9 >?B 9AE3 CGAA VB 8D8>B\7>GBE >9 >?B 9AE= '8 A9:H 78 CB 9 >?B >B;\8 7:E >?B\B8 9[ >?G8 8D8>B\7>G< ;BA7>G9:8?GR3 >?B;B[9;B3 CB 7;BB:>G>ABE >9 B^RB ;BHJA7;G>D 9[


86/360

;7C \B:e G: >?B d:7>G9:7A


87/360

R9AG>GG9:= #?G8 B:EB:9C7;E EJ7A 8D8>B\8 9JH?> :9>3 ?9CB@B;3>9 VAG:E J8 >9 >?B 9B;:8=MO

#?B;B G83 [9; B^7\RAB3 7 @B;D G:>B;B8>G:H >B:EB:9C7;E>?B [9;\7>G9: 9[ >B;:7;D 8D8>B\83 8J


88/360

89\B>?G:H 8G\GA7;= /: R7;>G9 ?98B G>G@B MXR7>a>B;:8 G:C?G


89/360

87GE >?7> \J


90/360


91/360

G:EBRB:EB:GA >?B A7>>B; G8 :BJ>;7AG`BE= *7>B;3 [;9\ >?G8 VBHG::G:H G: >?BB^?GVG>G9: 9[ G:EBRB:EB:?B G:EG@GEJ7A \7D 89\B>G\B8 H9 9: G: 7EJA> AG[B >9 8?9C9[[ 8JB;: R;9V7VAD ;B8B\VAB8 >?B '\B;G?B

7;;7:HB\B:> 9[ >?B R7G;BE 7;D ;9AB83 7G:AD G> EG[[B;8 [;9\ >?B'\B;G?7> >?B [7>?B;l8 E9\G:7:


92/360

?B \9>G[8 9[ G:>B;RB;89:7A 7:E G:>B;H;9JR ;BA7>G9:a8?GR 78 9J; 9:7>G9:7A R;B[B; 7;B

AG]BAD >9 VB EG8>J;VG:H=ITQ "G:? '\B;G B:B;HB>G9 8D\\B>;GG\JAG3 CB 8?7AA VB @B;D J:CG8B G[ CB 89[>aRBE7A >?B EG878>B;8 9[ C7;= /[ 9J; B:B\GB8EB[B7> J8 7> 7:D R9G:>3 >?7> [7 9JH?> >9 VB J8BE >9 >?B \7^G\J\ 78 7 >9 VB G: :9 ?J;;D >9 >BAA J8 >?7> dB:B\D 7E@7: >?B 8>JED 9[ :7>G9:7A EG[[B;B:?;9CJR9: >?B R;9VAB\8 9[ >?B RB77VAB=

cB ?7@B >9 EB@G8B 7 RB7;B7>D K$T 8J


93/360


94/360

."2 N:;B? 5@8 Z:;>8 OAE98L C9JAE VB 7: 9@B;8G\RAG[GG9:fG> C9JAE B@B: VB [7A8B f>9 87D >?7> 8


95/360

7G: ?BJ;G8>G< 7E@7:


96/360

8A9C8 E9C: 7:E JA>G\7>BAD ;B@B;8B8 >?B 8GH: 9[ C7;AG]B B[[9;>= c?7> C783 ?9CB@B;3;B_JG;BE >9 EB8


97/360

G:H 7:E A9@B\7]G:H3 >?B8D\V9AG< GEB:>G[GG9:8 9[ 9;H78\ CG>? EB7>?3 >?B ;B J8B VD \7\\7A8 9[9;H7:8 9[ 9[[B:8B 78 9;:7\B:>8 9[ 8B^J7A 7>>;7>G9:3 B>


98/360


99/360

@7;G9J8 783 VJ> ?G8 RA7 VB 7A>B;BE= "?9JAE ?B A7>B; ;B>J;: >9 9;>?9E9^D7:E VB 79 ?G8 9;GHG:7A R98G>G9: G: ;BA7>G9: >9 >?B 9>?B;\B\VB;8=OO

#?B [9;BH9G:H EB8G@B HB:B;7AG`7>G9:8 7;B 7AA R7;>G7A 7:8CB;8 >9 7 :BH7>G@B_JB8>G9:fec?D G8 F7AG:B8B 89D :9:8


100/360

ITQ /: >?BG; B;7:87G9:8 >?B F7AG:B8B 8?9C 7 H;B7> EB7A 9[ ?BG; 8\7AA EB7AG:H8= #?BD 7;B dRB::D CG8B=e &: >?B 9>?B; ?7:E3 >?G8 B7EGAD \7^G\G`G:H >?BG; CB7A>? 9; R;9RB;>DL>?B8B [BC 7;B R7;>AD EG8AG]BE 7:E R7;>AD ;BH7;EBE 78 9EEG>GB8= -9; >?B @78> \7K9;G>D>?B d87@G:H 9[ RB::GB8e G8 E9:B CG>? $ AG\G>BE >G\B RB;8RBG@B 7:E 7 AG\G>BE AB@BA 9[78RG;7>G9:= #?BD 7;B 87@G:H J:>GA >?BD ?7@B B:9JH? >9 8RB:E A7;HBAD 9: 89\B EB8>B\R> >9 \7^G\G`B @7AJB3 VJ> ;7>?B; CG>? >?B ;BA7^7>G9: 98G9:8 9[R?D8G9A9HD 7:E B:HG:BB;G:H3 ;B7AG`G:H >?7> :9> 9:AD G8 >?G8 7:7A9HD EB8G@B 9[>?BG; 8B_JB:;7:87G9:83 VJ> >?7> >?BD >?B\8BA@B8 8BB >?B8B 8B_JB:J;7AAD ?7@G:H 89\B 8J >9HB>?B;3 G> G8 :B?BD ?7> >?BG; ;BA7>G@B B R98G>G9:8 VB 8>7>BE= &:BCGAA 78] >?B 9>?B;3 dc?B;B E9 D9J 8G>je 7:E >?G8 G8 7 \B>7R?9; [9; B= /> G8 78]G:H3B88B:>G7AAD3 d09 D9J 8G> ?GH? 9; A9Cje c?B: B7 G> G8 J8J7AAD :B9 \7]B 7 G9: >9 >?B 9 R7D [9; >?B\= "G\GA7;AD3 G: ;BH7;E >9 >?B9[[B;G:H8 C?G


101/360

A988 9[ H;9JR \B\VB;8?GR >?7> >?B >?;B7> 9[ >?G8 A988 G8 9:B 9[ >?B \98> 8B;G9J887:G9:8 G: >?B J;B=

IXQ /> G8 9[ H;B7> G:>B;B8> >9 :9>B >?7> \7:D F7AG:B8B 7G9:8 7;B 7;>GBAD7?7: G: >B;\8 9[ G:EG@GEJ7A H97A8 9;

@7AJB8=OX

#?G8 G8 \98> BE >9 >?B @GAA7HB = IcB \7D HJB88 >?7> 7 0J;]?BG\G7: 7:7AD8G8 C9JAE 8BB\ >9 >?BF7AG:B8B >9 VB 7: 9V@G9J8 7:E 7RR;9R;G7>B 7RR;97


102/360

7H7G:8> >?B 9;EB; 7:E :7>J;7A 8>;JJ;B 9[ >?B J:G@B;8B ;7>?B; >?7: 7H7G:8> >?B 7J7ARB;89: 9[[B:EBE= #?B 9[[B:EB;3 B@B: G: 8J


103/360

9[ >?B 89


104/360

R7GE JR 7:E B@B;Da>?G:H CGAA 8>7;> 7H7G: [;9\ $ 8$M=%$ 3$'$, /: ?J\7: 89D AG[B G8 :9>RJ:J7>BE G: >?G8 C7D3 7:E B7


105/360

7\9:H >?B RA7DB;8= *B> J8 [J;>?B; 8JRR98B >?7> >?B RA7DB;8 7;B AG7VAB >9 B?3 >?7> 9J; J\RG;B G8 ?7> >?G8 8?7AA :9> 9 >?BJ\RG;B ?78 R9CB; >9 \7]B 7G: 7A>B;7>G9:8 G: >?B ;JAB8 9[ >?B H7\B 9; G: >?BR;9V7VGAG>GB8 7889BE CG>?


106/360

%$#,@I 2&+*#> H#"+:+ *B# 2*#)?& 2*)*#

/ ?7@B EG8C9 >DRB8 9[ 89B\ G: 8J


107/360

/> G8 B@GEB:> >?7> >?B B>?98 7A9:B G8 G:8J[[G >9 \7G:>7G: >?B 8>B7ED 8>7>B= -;9\ >G\B>9 >G\B >?B @GAA7HB 9; 89\B 9>?B; B:>G>D E9B8 8>BR G: >9 J;B9[ >?B8B G:8>7:?B C9;]G:H 9[ >?B


108/360

."T O9A;8\ FJ:K8\ :CG 3C[>B\R>8 G8 BAD8JB\R>8 E9 :9> 78 DB> \BB> G: >?B \GEEAB 9[ >?B >B;;G>9;D >9VB \7RRBE3 G>= \7D VB J8B[JA >9 8>7>B3 G: :9:a>B


109/360

EG[[B;B:> [;9\ >?B R?D8G?B R?D8G?7> 9[ V9>?=

':E B@B: C?B: >?B 8JVKB \7>>B; 9[ 7;> G8 >?B [;J8>;7>G9: 9[ G:>BH;7>G9:3 ?B R;9EJ8 9[ >?G8 [;J8>;7>G9: G8 :9> >99 8J;R;G8G:H=

#?B ;7A _JB8>G9: G8b /: C?7> [9;\ G8 G:[9;\7>G9: 7V9J> R8D


110/360

C?7> G8 9: >?B 9>?B; 8GEB 9[ >?B 8A78? \7;]= cB \7D 87D >?7> C?7> G8 9: 9:B 8GEB 9[>?B 8A78? 7G:8 (# C?7> G8 9: >?B 9>?B; 8GEB= &;3 G:B:HG:BB;l8 A7:HJ7HB3 >?B 7HH;BH7>B 7G:8 d;BEJ:E7:?B R9G:>9[ @GBC 9[ 7 G< 9V8B;@B;3 >?B G:[9;\7>G9: 7@7GA7VAB 9: 9:B 8GEB 9[ >?B 8A78?

CGAA ;B8>;7G: IG=B=3 ;BEJ?B R;9V7VGAG>D 9[Q C;9:H HJB88G:H= $^7\RAB8b#?B AB>>B; # G: 7 HG@B: A9G9: G: 7 RGB>B: $:HAG8? R;98B R;9R98B8 >?7>>?B :B^> AB>>B; G8 AG]BAD >9 VB 7: 1 9; 7: 2 9; 7 @9CBA= /> G8 R988GVAB >9 \7]B 7 VB>>B;>?7: ;7:E9\ HJB88 7


111/360

>?B ;7G:aE;9R8= /: [73 [BC RB9RAB G: >?G8 8G>J7>G9: ;B8>;7G: >?B\a8BA@B8 [;9\8BB\G:HAD EJRAGG:H >?BG; G:[9;\7>G9: VD A99]G:H 9J> 9[ >?B CG:E9C= cB AG]B >9R;9@B >?7> 9J; HJB88B8 7;B ;GH?>3 7:E >?7> 9J; [;GB:E8 7;B ?9:B8>= ">GAA \9;B G\R9;>7:>3F6 %(S6 82 86'8 23 E63( R9G:> G8 :9:>;G@G7A= /> GAAJ8>;7>B8 >?B :B


112/360

d/ ]:9C >?B C7D >9 )7\V;GEHBe \GH?> \B7: >?7> / ?7@B 8>JEGBE >?B \7R 7:E \GH?> \B7: >?7> / ?B ;9J>B= /> \GH?>\B7: >?7> C?B: E;G@G:H >?7> ;9J>B / 3652:#(\6 \7:D EB>7GA8 B@B: >?9JH? / \B7: >?7> C?B: E;G@G:H >9 )7\V;GEHB / ;J8> >9 d?7VG>e >9

\7]B \B >J;: 7> >?B ;GH?> R9G:>83 CG>?9J> ?7@G:H >9 8I(#S C?B;B / 7\ H9G:H= ':E 899:=/: 7AA ? 7 ;BEJ:E7:>B;:G:H 9[ 7 _JG>B b

hId/ ]:9Csem\D \G:EQmm>?B ;97Ei7:E >?B EG[[GD G8 >9 EB>B;\G:B >?B :7>J;B 9[ >?B R7>>B;:G:H CG>?G: >?B ;9J:E

V;783 9;3 >9 RJ> >?B \7>>B; 7:9>?B; C7Db C?7> +$38' 9[ >?B \G:E 7;B ;BEJ:E7:>CG>? >?B R7;>G d]:9CG:H=e

*78>3 >?B;B G8 7 8RB


113/360

E;B7\B;= ':E >?G8 \7D VB >;JB 9[ >?98B G>B\8 9[ G:[9;\7>G9: C?G8 C?G


114/360

G:J9J8AD B^


115/360

)AB7;AD3 ?G8 >78] G8 G\R988GVAB3 VJ>3 78 ?78 VBB: ;B\7;]BE3 89\B RB9RAB E9 G> @B;DR;B>>GAD=

G8 8>;JJ;BE G: >B;\8 9[ >?B A9HG?B 7AH9;G>?\8 9[ >?B J: >?B 7A89 >?B [7 >?7> C?B:8J8 9[


116/360

I-9; 7 8


117/360

'AA >?G8 G:EGB8 >?7> R;G\7;DaR;9?9JH?>8 7:E >?B 8 >9 9>?B;8 7;B3 G: 7: B@9AJ>G9:7;D 8B:8B3 \9;B 7;


118/360

G\R9;>7:? C?G


119/360

C78 :9>BE 7V9@B >?7> >?B B:> 9[ 3 7 8\7AA R7;> 9[ >;J>? 7V9J> >?B 8BA[= FJ> G[ >?G8

R7;> VB '6%65869 G: 7:D 8D8>B\7>G< \7::B;3 G> G8 7G: >?7> >?B R7;>G7A >;J>?8 9[9;>G9: 9[ >?B >;J>? 9[ 89\B A7;HB; C?9AB=

/: >?B 9[8>J[[ G8 VBA9CL VJ> CB \7]B >?B 87\B 89;> 9[ B^>;7R9A7>G9: [;9\ >?B B:> 9[ \B;BAD >?B 8BABG@G>D 9[ R;B[B;B:?B 8]BAB>9:87?B -;BJEG7: J: \7]B8 8J


120/360

/: 7 C9;E3 >?B J:7GEBE ?B 89;> 9[8>JRGEG>D 9[ C?G


121/360

8RB7]3 [;7HGAB= /> C9JAE VB V;9]B: 9; G:>B;;JR>BE VD 8\JEHB8 9; G;;BHJA7;G>GB8 9[ 8G`B9; >9:B G: >?B R7G:>G:H 9[ >?B 8JG8> A99]8 7> >?B C9;] 9[ 7:9>?B;3 9:B 9[ >?B [G;8> >?G:H8 ?BB^7\G:B8 G8 >?B >BAD ;BEB[G:BE CG>? RB: 7:E VA7?G8 ?78 VBB: E9:B [9; 7AA >?B AB7@B83 >?B 7;>G8> VBHG:8 >9 R7G:> CG>? V;J8? 7:E )?G:B8BG:]= $7


122/360

C%+@*@%,

IMQ #?B EBAG:B7>G9: 9[ AB7@B8 7:E 9>?B; [9;\8 E9B8 :9> ;B7


123/360

/> G8 8>GAA R988GVAB3 ?9CB@B;3 >?7> 89\B>?G:H G8 7EEBE >9 9J; J:EB;8>7:EG:H 9[ 7C9;] 9[ 7;> VD >?B ?DR9>?B8G8 >?7> >?B 8JVKB \7>>B; G8 E9JVABb >?7> >?B RGJ;B;BR;B8B:>8 V9>? >?B 8>7;> 9[ 7 G9: R;9? @7HG:7= cG>? 7AG>>AB G\7HG:7>G9:3 CB ?B RGJ;B 78 7 8D\V9AG< ;BR;B8B:>7>G9: 9[

F7AG:B8B 89G9: G: C?G


124/360

."V + 9[ 78 89\B?9CR;G\7;D3 >?B ;BA7>7 78 8B?G83 G> G8 ?7> >?B ;BA7>G9:8 7;B 9[ >?B89;> HB:B;7>BE VD R;9G9: B^a


125/360

c?7> ?78 VBB: 87GE 7V9@B CGAA 8B;@B 78 8J[[G EB[G:G>G9: 9[ C?7> G8 ?B;B \B7:>VD d[9;\ 7:E R7>>B;:=e#?B [9?7: B:>3JR9: B^> ;7>?B; >?7: JR9: C?7> 93 JR9: ;BA7>G9:8?GR;7>?B; >?7: JR9: >?B ;BA7>BE RB;a89:8 9; R?B:9\B:7=

#?B B887D8 G: >?7> >?B R;9f9; \J8> fVB EJB >9 R;9H;B88G@BG:>B;7G9: VB>CBB: 9;H7:G8\8= 5:EB; :7>J;7A 8BABG9:3 8J


126/360

3 5)"* 6667 =%"> ),? 5)*B%9%$& @,

E#9)*@%,+B@C


127/360

2"! O?B A78> G>B\ ZUG: 0;= .B7El8 8J\\7;D 9[?B; R7RB;= #9 >?B A7D\7: C?9 ?78 :9> 9?B G@B 8>JED9[ ?J\7: J;B83 >?G8 ;BG9: \7D 7RRB7; 8>;7:HBL G> \7D 7RRB7; >9 VB 7:B>?G?7> CB EG897


128/360

9[ 8B RB9RAB3 CB 8?7AA 7;;G@B 7> 7 >9>7AG>7;G7: ;7>?B; >?7: 7EB\9G< 8D8>B\ 9[ AG[B=e #?B 89AJ>G9: C?G


129/360

>?7> CB ?7@B >?B >B

>?98B 9[ J83 7> AB78>3 [9; C?9\ 8G[JA 7:EEGH:G[GBE 7V8>;7G9:= *B> J8 >;D >9 8J;\9J:> >?G8 7EEG>G9:7A 89J;J;:G:H >?B >99A8 9[ 8 9[ G:8>;J\B:>7A >?9JH?> 7:E JR9: >?B:BC ?7VG> C?G


130/360

C?9AB R?GA989R?D 9[ AG[BL G> CGAA ?BG; [J>J;B 7>>G>JEB8 >9aC7;E 7J>?9;G>D=c?B:B@B; >?BD \BB> 7G: 89;>8 9[ B^>3 >?BD CGAA >B:E >9 8BB >?B8B B^>8 788>;JJ;BE 9: 7: B7;AGB; [7\GAG7; R7>>B;:= #?B VAJBR;G:>B; \7D EB;G@B 7: G:G>G7A7E@7:>7HB [;9\ >?B


131/360

B7 R;9@GEB J8CG>? 89\B>?G:H 7RR;97L VJ> G[ CB ]:BC ?9C >?G8 ?7VG> G8;BA7>BE >9 9>?B;83 CB \GH?> VB 7VAB >9 KJEHB 9[ >?B VB:B[G>8 7:E E7:HB;83 >?B R988GVAB

RG>[7AA8 9[ 8J


132/360

R;B7>B\B:> 9[ \D \B7:G:H= / \J8> EB\9:8>;7>B 7> AB78> \D CGAAG:H:B88 >9 8>7>B>?G8 V;GEHB VB>CBB: 8G\RAB AB7;:G:H 7:E HB8>7A> G: 9RB;7>G9:7A >B;\8=

*B> J8 C9 C9;E83 dR;9>9aAB7;:G:He7:E dEBJ>B;9AB7;:G:H3e >9 7@9GE >?B A7V9;9[ EB[G:G:H 9RB;7>G9:7AAD 7AA >?B 9>?B; >B;\8 G: >?B [GBAE I>;7:8[B; 9[ AB7;:G:H3

HB:B;7AG`7>G9:3 B> J8 87D >?7> >?B;B 7;B >C9 89;>8 9[ H;7EGB:> EG8 7> 7:D R9G:> 9: 7 8G\RAB AB7;:G:H


133/360

/: >?G8 EB[G:G>G9: 9[ R;9>9a 7:E EBJ>B;9aAB7;:G:H3 9:B R?;78B ;B\7G:88=e -9; RJ;R98B8 9[GAAJ8>;7>G9:3 / G\7HG:BE 7 8B;GB8 9[ B^RB;G\B:>8 G: ;9>B AB7;:G:H3 B7


134/360

G:EG@GEJ7A G: 7 CG>? 7: G\RB;89:7A B@B:>8 8>;B7\3 VJ> ;7>?B; CG>? ;B7AG:EG@GEJ7A8 C?9 ?7@B G9:7A R7>>B;:8 9[ ;BA7>G9:8?GR CG>? 9>?B;G:EG@GEJ7A8= /: 8J8 9[ >?B B^RB;G\B:>7A

R8D


135/360

#?B8B 7;B


136/360

98 7\9:H \B: 9[ @7;G9J8 J;B8= &[H;B7>B8> G:>B;B8>fVB [7\GAG7;f7;B >?B %7@A9@G7: R7>a>B;:8 7:E >?B R7>>B;:89[ ;9>B= /> G8 7 AG>>AB ?7;E [9; \B\VB;8 9[ cB8>B;: G9: >9 VBAGB@B >?7> C?9AB8D8>B\8 9[ VB?7@G9; 9: R;B\G8B8 9>?B; >?7: 9J; 9C: \G^>J;B 9[

G:8>;J\B:>7A ;BC7;E 7:E G:8>;J\B:>7A 7@9GE7:9 AG@B 7 AG[B C?98B 8>?;9JH? %7@A9@G7: 8RB7AD >G:>BE CG>? >?B ?9RB 9[ G:8>;J\B:>7A;BC7;E3 C?GAB >?B AG[B 9[ >?B F7AG:B8B G8 8B:8GVAB G[ CB 7
? G:8>;J\B:>7A 7@9GE7:9 >?B dRJ;Be %7@A9@G7:3 9:AD 7 @B;D AG\G>BE [7>7AaG8\ C9JAE VB R988GVAB=1B C9JAE 8BB 7AA B@B:>8 78 R;B9;E7G:BE 7:E ?B C9JAE 8BB ?G\8BA[ 78 [7>BE 9:AD >98B7;


137/360

78 7 \B7:8 >9 7: B:E= #?B;B G83 ?9CaB@B;3 9:B @B;D G\R9;>7:> EG[[B;B:CBB: >?BF7AG:B8B R7>>B;: 7:E >?7> ;B>B;: G8B88B:>G7AAD EB;G@7>G@B [;9\ B^>8 9[ G:8>;J\B:>7A 7@9GE7:?BD 8BB >?B C9;AE 78E7:HB;9J83 7:E >?B\8BA@B8 78 7@9GEG:H3 VD >?B B:EAB88 ;9>B VB?7@G9; 9[ ;G>J7A 7:E

B8D3 >?B B@B;aR;B8B:> ;G8] 9[


138/360

2", * 5@8


139/360


140/360

'?B #?B9;D 9[ *9HG 7:E ?B GEB7A3 2J88BAA C9JAE:9> G: [7 ?7@B [9;\JA7>BE >?B GEB7A=

IYQ ' ;BA7>BE R;9VAB\ G: >?B B@9AJ>G9: 9[ B;;G>9;D ;BA7>G9:b >?B [7 >?7> 7 \B887HB3 9[C?7>B@B; ]G:E3 E9B8 :9> 9[ >?98B 9VKB8 C?G


141/360

>?BG; ;99>8 G: >?B G9: 9[ >?;B7> 7:E RA7D= /> G8 B@GEB:> 7A89 >?7> :9> 9:AD >?;B7>VJ> >?B ;Bf>?B VB?7@G9; 9[ >?B >?;B7>B:BE G:EG@GEJ7Af7;B 7 R7;> 9[>?G8 G8 R;9V7VAB >?7> :9> 9:AD ?G8>;G9:G 7A89 8RB7>9;8?GR 8?9JAE VBG:?G: >?G8 [GBAE= /> G8 7A89 7RR;9R;G7>B >9 \B:>G9: 8BA[aRG>D=

INQ ' [J;>?B; B^>B:8G9: 9[ >?G8 >?G:]G:H AB7E8 J8 >9 G:J7A CG>?G: >?G8HB:B;7A [GBAE G: C?G


142/360

>?B O0 8?B G:>B:8G>D 9[ :GH?>\7;B= '> >?B \9\B:> 9[ >B;;9; >?B;B C78 :9 _JB8>G9:G:H 9[d;B7AG>D3e VJ> 8>GAA >?B;B C78 :9 8RB7; G: >?B \9@GB ?9J8B 7:E :9 ?B VBE;99\=#?B G\7HB8 EGE :9> EB:9>B >?7> C?G


143/360

R8D


144/360

;7>BE VD EG7H;7\8 G: C?G


145/360

J:EB;8>7:EG:H >?B 7G:BE \B887HB8 VD ;B\G:EG:H >?B >?G:]B; >?7> >?B8B \B887HB87;B \J>J7AAD ;BAB@7:> 7:E >?B \B887HB8 9J>8GEB >?B [;7\B \7D VB GH:9;BE=

IEQ /: >?B 8B:8B 9[ >?B R;B@G9J8 R7;7H;7R?3 7 [;7\B G8 \B>7


146/360

IMNQ #?G8 C?9AB \7>>B; 9[ [;7\B8 7:E R7;7E9^B8 \7D VB GAAJ8>;7>BE G: >B;\8 9[7:G\7A VB?7@G9;3 C?B;B >?;BB >DRB8 9[ \B887HB \7D VB ;B C?G


147/360

9[ >?B;7RD3 >?B;B \J8> ?7@B VBB: 7 AB@BA ;68$ 82 >?B8B ;JAB8= #?B;B\J8> ?7@B VBB: $ 5I$#:6 G: ;JAB8=

FJ> 8J


148/360

R;9?G:]G:H3 C?G 9; 8?9JAE 9VBD >?B#?B9;D 9[ *9HG?BG; ?BG; [7GAJ;B >9 E9 >?G8 G8 :9> EJB >9\B;B ?7> >?B R7;7E9^B8 9[ 7V8>;7G9:\J8> \7]B >?BG; 7RRB7;7: 9[ \99Ea8GH:7A83 7:E >?7> CG>?9J> >?B8B R7;7E9^B8 >?B B@9AJ>G9: 9[ 7: B:E= *G[B C9JAE >?B: VB 7: B:EAB88 G:>B;


149/360


150/360

*99] @B;D >?B A9HG;JJ;B 9[ >?7> A78> _J9>7>G9:= /> G8 B;7G9: 7:E 8>;7GH?>B: 9J> >?B \G8J:EB;8>7:EG:H C787A89 R;9?GVG>BE=

&: 7:9>?B; 9?B \9;:G:H3 7:E /CB:> 9@B; >9 >?B EG:G:H ?7AA 7> 8JRRB; >G\B >9 8BB ?G\ 7:E 788J;B ?G\ >?7> ?B C9JAE8BB \B :B^> E7D= 1B ;B[J8BE >9 A99] 7> \B= 1B A99]BE 7C7D= / \7EB 89\B ;B\7;]7V9J> N=OW >?B :B^> \9;:G:Hf:9 7:8CB;= #?B:3 CG>? H;B7> EG[[GD3 ?B 87GE3 d#?BKJEHB EG87RR;9@B8=e FBa[9;B / AB[> ?G\3 / 87GE3 d,9J :BBE 7 EB[B:8B 7>>9;:BD3e 7:EC?B: / [9J:E ?G\ 9: >?B H;9J:E8 :B^> \9;:G:H / 87GE3 d1B;B G8 D9J; EB[B:8B7>>9;:BD3e 7:E CB CB:> G:>9 8B88G9: >9HB>?B;= / 8>7;>BE 9J> VD 87DG:H3 d'\ / ;GH?> G:8JRR98G:H >?7> >?B KJEHB :9> 9:AD EG87RR;9@B8 9[ D9J; >7A]G:H >9 \B VJ> 7A89EG87RR;9@B8 9[ D9J; >BAAG:H \B >?7> ?B EG87RR;9@B8je 1B 87GE3 d,B8pe #?7> G83 CB 7;BEB7AG:H CG>? >C9 AB@BA8 ?B;B= #?B dKJEHBe EG87RR;9@B8 9[ >?B 7>>B\R> >9 8>;7GH?>B:9J> >?B ?B KJEHBl8Q

EG87RR;9@7A=cB ?7@B >9 A99] [9; 7: B>G9A9HD G:@9A@G:H \JA>GRAB AB@BA8 9[ >;7J\7=/ 7\ :9> >7A]G:H 7> 7AA 7V9J> >?B B:> 9[ >?B8B >;7J\7>G< 8B_JB:?B;

>?BD VB 8B^J7A3 9; 9;7A= (9; 7\ / >7A]G:H 7V9J> >?B 7HB 9[ >?B 8JVKB 7> >?B >G\B 9[>;7J\73 :9; 7V9J> C?G


151/360

cB 7AA \7]B B;;9;8 9[ >?7> ]G:E 7> @7;G9J8 >G\B8= /l\ :9> 8J;B >?7> /l@B B@B; \B>7:DV9ED >?7> E9B8:l> 8J[[B; [;9\ d8


152/360

?7@B G: ?B; ?9J8B 89\B>?G:H >?7> C78 dV9>? VB7J>G[JA 7:E J:>GED=e d&?pe 8?B 87GE3d#?98B 7;B :9> J:>GED [A9CB;8= '8 B7


153/360

2"2 5


154/360

8 \B\VB;83 CB 7;HJB >?7> G: >?B R8D


155/360

VB>CBB: VJ``B; 7:E \B7> R9CEB;3 >?G8 8B_JB:B; 78 7\B887HB G:EGG:H >?7> d#?B E9H ?78 %6$3#69 >?7> VJ``B; \B7:8 \B7> R9CEB;=e FJ>>?G8 G8 :9> >?B B:E 9[ >?B ?GB;7;


156/360

B>G9A9HD VJ> ;7>?B; [9;


157/360

>?B ;BG:[9; 7> >?B 9>?B; >C9 AB@BA8 G:@9A@B8 7 >?;B7> >9 8J;@G@7A3 7:E G[ >?BE9JVAB VG:E8 7;B G\R98BE EJ;G:H G:[7:8BB\8 >?7> G: 89\B ?B B8?B [GBAE G8 \7EB G\R988GVAB VD 7G:EB@G G: 7 E9JVAB VG:E 8G>J7>G9:3 ?B CGAA ;B8R9:E EB[B:8G@BAD G: 7 \7::B;8G\GA7; >9 >?B 8AD3 dcBAA3 ?9C EGE D9J HB> 8I636j[

796= %B;


158/360

#?B B\RA9DBB ;BRAGBE3 dFD 7J>9\9VGAB=e 1B ;B8R9:EBE AG>B;7AAD VB G: 7 E9JVAB VG:E= -9; B^7\RAB3 7 R7>GB:> \7D CG8?>9 G?B;7RG8> [9; VBG:H A7>B [9; 7: 7RR9G:>\B:>3 VJ> ?B \7D VB J:8J;B C?7>89;> 9[ 7 \B887HB >?7> 7 9[ VBG:H A7>B C78fR7;>G?B >?B;7RG8> ?78

7:>GBE >?B R7>GB:>l8 ;B7G9: 7:E 7R9A9HG`BE [9; >?B B@B:>= #?B R7>GB:> 87D3 dc?D CB;B D9J A7>Bj /8 G> VB C7:> >9 8BB \B >9E7Dje #?G8 C9JAEVB 7: 78 >9 7 \B>7R?9;G7>B\B:>= 1B \7D >?B: 87D3 d/]:BC 7 [BAA9C 9:3 ?G8 :7\B C78 "7\ 7:E >?B V97> 7A\98>8J:]3s B>7R?9;G9;D 7:E >?B >?B;7RG8> \7D 9; \7D:9> EG8 7 9: ?G8 VBG:H A7>B= #?B >?G:H 7V9J> 7\B>7R?9; G8 >?7> G> AB7@B8 G> JR >9 >?B >?B;7RG8> I9; \9>?B;Q >9 8BB 7: 7?B8>7>B\B:> G[ ?B


159/360


160/360

>?B 8GH:7A8 C?G EB[B:E ?G\8BA[ VD 3 [9; B^7\RAB3 788J\B >?7> VB?G:E B@B;D

8>7>B\B:> >?B;B G8 7 B8>7VAG8? 7 R7>>B;: 9[ A7JH?G:H 9[[ >?B8B \B>7;DG:H >9 EG8B VB>CBB: AB@BA8 9[ \B887HB 7:E >;B7> 7AA\B887HB8 78 J:G\R9;>7:> 9; >9 VB A7JH?BE 7>=

/[ ?B EGE:l> VBB\R> >9A7JH? >?B\ 9[[3 ?B \GH?>


161/360

B\ C?G


162/360

8G\RAGD G: >?G8 R;B8B:>7>G9: CB 8?7AA 9 >C9 9;EB;8=Q #?B8B 9;EB;89[ \B887HB


163/360

7:E C9JAE BG>?B; RJ:G8? ?G\ [9; CG>?E;7CG:H 9; 7RR;97


164/360

:9> 9:AD [BBA B:E7:HB;BE 7H7G:3 VJ> 8?B \7D ;B8B:> >?B [7 >?7> 8?B ?7E >9 [9;9 ;B8R9:E= /: BG>?B; G9:8?GR3 >?B \98> G\R9;>7:> G: ?G8 AG[B 7:E >?B\9EBA [9; 7AA 9>?B;83 ?B G8 RJ:G8?BE G[ ?B G:EGB8 A9@B 7:E 7[[BG9: 7:E RJ:G8?BE G[?B E9B8 :9>L 7:E ?G8 B8B8 [;9\ >?B 8G>J7>G9:3 8J


165/360


166/360

C9;E83 d+;7:E\9\\D ;B7AAD A9@B8 D9J=e /> G8 8GH:G[G >?7> >?B H;7:E\9>?B; >99]>?B 7>>G>JEB >9aC7;E >?B R7>GB:> >?7> 8?B C78 :9> CBAA B:9JH? ;9AABE3 7:E 8?BJ8BE >9 B; [9; VBG:H >99 B78D 9: >?B G: >?;9CG:H @7;G9J8 9VKB8 7> >?B \9>?B; 7:E H;7:E\9>?B; C?GAB >?BD?B; [BA> ?B;8BA[ @B;D 7>>;7G@B 78 7 HG;A3 7:E 8?B [BA> >?7> ?B; E7JH?>B;

;B8B\VABE ?B; ;7>?B; ?9JH? VD E7\:G:H CG>? [7G:> R;7G8B3 G> C78 9V@G9J8>?7> 8?B [BA> >?B E7JH?>B; EB[G:G>BAD ;7: 8B?B E7JH?>B;l8 [G;8> 78EJ;G:H 7 R8DB; ?7E ?7E >?;BB R;B@G9J8 ?98RG>7AG`7>G9:83>?B \9>?B; ?7E :B@B; \B:>G9:BE >9 >?B E99;8 >?7> 8?B ?B;8BA[ ?7E ?7E 7 R8DB; 7:E ?B; ?J8V7:E= 'H7G:8> \BEGB; 9J> 9[ >?B;7RD=

#?B [7>?B; C78 78 G:@9A@BE G: >?B ?9\B98>7>G< 78RB8 9[ >?B G:>;7[7\GAD 8G>J7>G9:78 >?B \9>?B;= -9; B^7\RAB3 ?B 8>7>BE >?7> ?B ?7E >9 _JG> ?G8 R98G>G9: 78 7: G\R9;>7:>7>>9;:BD G: 9;EB; >9 V;G:H ?G8 E7JH?>B; >9 7: 7;B7 C?B;B B:> R8D


167/360

ITQ #?B R8D G:>9 >?B [9;;7;GCG8B3 ?B \7D VB?B; B^RB;> G: 8B>>G:H E9JVAB VG:E

8G>J7>G9:8 ?G\8BA[=IOQ '?B9;D3 >?B J7>G9: EB8G7A >9>?B \9>?B;l8 8BD3 7:E VD G:[B;B:9 >?B [7\GAD ?9\B98>78G8= /[ >?G8 VB 893 >?B:C?B: R8D


168/360

d;B7AG>D=e #?B E;7\7 G8 B8RBB;B8>G:H G: >?G8 ;B8RB3 CG>? V9>? RB;[9;\B;87:E 8RB7>9;8 ;B8R9:EG:H >9 \B887HB8 7V9J> V9>? >?B 7J7A 7:E >?B >?B7>;GD=

cB 7;B HG@G:H B^>B:8G@B 7>>B:>G9: >9 ?DR:98G8= ' H;B7> 7;;7D 9[ R?B:9\B:7 >?7>

9


169/360

CGAA R;9@GEB 7 ;B?B G:JG:H3 ;BRB>G>G@B E9JVAB VG:EG:HC?G


170/360

R7>GB:>l8 ?G8>9;D3 9; >?B R7>GB:> G8 G\R98G:H 7 E9JVAB VG:E 8G>J7>G9: 9: >?B >?B;7RG8>='> 9>?B; >G\B8 >?B;7RG8>8 8BB\ >9 G\R98B E9JVAB VG:E83 BG>?B; EBAGVB;7>BAD 9;G:>JG>G@BAD3 C?G


171/360


172/360

'AA >?G83 ?9CB@B;3 ?78 VBB: VB>>B; 7:E \9;B ;GH9;9J8AD 87GE VD FB;>7A7:[[D3 C?G


173/360

AG>>AB \9;B 7AG@B >?7: >?B E;D V9:B8 9[ >?B R;9H;7\ C?G


174/360

EB>B;\G:BE VD BAA7>G9:8 9[ HB:B>G< \B887HB8= #?G8 G8 :9> >?B RA7


175/360

E9JV> >?7> 7 A7;HB R7;> 9[ 8VD >?B


176/360

C?7> C9JAE VB RJ> 9: >?B R;98 9[ >?B >BABH;7R? [9;\ 7:E CGAA \9EG[D >?B>B^> 9[ ?G8 \B887HB >9 EG8>9;> 9; 9\G> 7:D G:EGG9: 9[ >?B8B \B>78 G: >?B >9>7A :9;\7A \B887HB= c?7> ;B\7G:8 G8 AG]BAD >9 VB 7 \B>7R?9;G7>B\B:> J:A7VBAABE 78 >9 B^>= &;3 G: B^>;B\B ?B;B \7D VB :9>?G:H AB[> VJ>

7 8>9AGE 7G:H 9J> 9[ >?B \B887HB3 d#?B;B G8 :9 ;BA7>G9:8?GR VB>CBB: J8=e#?G8 \J >9


177/360

G:EGB >?7> ?B 8BB8 7:D \B>7 G8 ?7RRB:G:H= #?B R7>GB:> \7D ]:9C VJ>\J8> :9> >BAA3 7:E >?B;BVD B:7VAB8 >?B R7;B:> >9 :9> ]:9C C?7> ?B 9; 8?B G8 E9G:H=

#?B R7>GB:> G8 7: 7B\7>G9;>G9:8 9[?B8B EG8>9;>G9:8 7;B 7AC7D8 R;B?98B C?G >?B ;99\ 8BB\BE >9VB 7:E ?B ?B7;8 7 @9G= 1B;B "]B;>


178/360

"J


179/360

89AJ>G9: >9 89AJ>G9:3 7AC7D8 8BABG:H 7:9>?B; 89AJ>G9: C?G


180/360


181/360

2"V 7BCBL:; '8=>BJ8L8C9E [?B\ 78 G>8BA[3 VJ> 8>GAA >9 AB:E >?B\ G>8 >99A83 >9 V9;;9C >99A8 [;9\ >?B\3 7:E3HB:B;7AAD3 >9 ]BBR >?B :BGH?V9;G:H 8= cB \7D RB;?7R8 KJEHB 9[ >?BG\R9;>7:


182/360

\B>7B^> C?G= #?B 9;H7:G8\ G8 >?B: [7? >?B EGAB\\7 BG>?B; 9[ VBG:H C;9:H G: >?BR;G\7;D B^> 9; 9[ VBG:H ;GH?> [9; >?B C;9:H ;B789:8 9; G: 7 C;9:H C7D= #?G8 G8 >?B89aGH7>G:H >?B ?DR9>?B8G8 >?7> 8 C?G


183/360

.9;B9@B;3 >?B8B EG8G:JG>GB8 7;B 9[ 7 RBJ;B= / ?7@B 87GE >?7> >?BA7;HB; B^> \7D


184/360

AB7;:G:H3 7:E 7V9@B >?B8B 7: G:[G:G>B 8B;GB8


185/360

/> G8 :B >9 G:8G8> >?7> G: >?B C9;AE 9[ ?B 9:AD ;BAB@7:>B:>G>GB8 9; d;B7AG>GB8e 7;B \B887HB83 G:?G8 >B;\ R7;>8 9[ \B887HB83 ;BA7>G9:8VB>CBB: \B887HB83 8GH:G[G H7R8 G: \B887HB83 7:E 89 9:= AI6 +6356+8(2# 9[ 7: B@B:>9; 9VKB 9; ;BA7>G9: G8 ;B7A= /> G8 7 :BJ;9R?D8G9A9HG >?B tB@B:> G>8BA[ 9;

>?B 9VKB G>8BA[ B:>B; >?G8 C9;AE 7:E G83 >?B;B[9;B3 G;;BAB@7:> 7:E3 >9 >?7> B^>B:>3J:;B7A= )9:@B;8BAD3 7 \B887HB ?78 :9 ;B7AG>D 9; ;BAB@7:?B(BC>9:G7: C9;AEb G> >?B;B G8 ;BEJ9 89J:E C7@B8 9; R;G:>B;l8 G:]=

FD >?B 87\B >9]B:3 >?B dB^>8e 7:E dB^>8 9[ B^>8e JR9: C?G


186/360


187/360

AB7;:G:H 7:E >?B8B >C9 9>?B; V9EGB8 9[ ]:9CABEHB= / ;B[B;;BE B7;AGB; >9 >?B >?;BB8JVKB8 >9HB>?B; 78 7 >;G7E= #?B 8>;JJ;B 9[ >?G8 >;G7E CB \J8> :9C G


188/360

C9;AE 78 9;H7:G`BE JR9: \JA>GRAB 7:E 8BR7;7VAB R;G:G9:>?7> 89\7>G< ?78 9 ;B8B\VAB >?B B@9AJ>G9:7;D R;98 [J:E7\B:>7AAD8>9 7V9J>VD >?B HB:B VG>?9;7^= #?G8 HB:B ?78 @B;D R;9[9J:E B[[B8 JR9: >?B 7EJA> R?B:9>DRB=/: G>8 R;B8B:?B >?G;E 8BH\B:> 9[ >?B >?9;7^ G8 \9EG[GBE >9 ;B8B\VAB >?B 8B?B AG>>AB V7A7:B;B83 9: >?G8 >?G;E 8BH\B:> VB G8 7 [9J;aCG:HBE [AD= #?G8 [9J;aCG:HBE


189/360

7;>G[G


190/360

/> \7D VB :9>BE >?7> 8J


191/360

VB 7G: R9G:>8 G9:7A JR9: B:@G;9:\B:>7A [79;8= 27>?B;3 G> 8BB\8>?7> G: 8e \7:= /:EBBE3>?B ?J\9;G8>3 G:89[7; 78 ?B ?9H8 >?B B; 9[ >?B 8>7HB3 \7D ;BEJ?B;8 >9 >?BR98G>G9: 9[ ;B :9> >?B\8BA@B8 ;GVJ>G:H=

#?B8B G9:8


192/360

EBH;BB8 9[ 8


193/360

/[ CB 788J\B >?7> V9>? >?B H;988AD 8 VB ;BA7>BEG: 7 HB:B>G< >?B9;D=)B;>7G:AD3 :9 7:8CB; >9 >?G8 _JB8>G9: G8 7> R;B8B:> 7@7GAa7VAB3 VJ> G> G8 B EG8>G: R;9VAB\8= /: >?B ?B 9@B;>8 VB J:EB; 7 8G:HAB ?B7E VD 8JHHB8>G:H >?7> G: 89\B 8B:8B >?B87\B ;GHGEG>D 9RB;7>B8 7> EG[[B;B:> AB@BA8 G: >?B >C9 ]:9C=

FB >?7> 78 G> \7D3 >?B EG[[GGB8 C?G


194/360

R;9VAB\8 9[ 7E7R>7>G9: 7:E AB7;:G:H 7:E >?BG; R7>?9A9HGB8 \J8> VB B;\8 9[ 7 ?GB;7; B:?7:?BR?B:9>DRG< 7:E HB:9>DRG<


195/360

/ ?7@B >9J

7:8CB; \9;7A 9; 7B8>?B>G< _JB8>G9:8j/ VBAGB@B >?7> >?B R98G>G9: G8 8GH:G[GAD 7V9J>\7:D >G\B8= / \B7: >?B \7>>B; 9[ d;9Ae 7:E >?B C?9AB ;BA7>BE BEVD 8J


196/360

#?B G:[G:G>B ;BH;B88 9[ B^>8 C?G


197/360

7:3 VJ> >9E7D AB88 ?9:9;BE3 \9>G@Bb 7 D 7V9J> >?B C9;AE 9[ C?G


198/360

3 d+B:B>G< '88G\GA7>G9: 9[ 7: 'G9:3 MNYO3 Pb MMUaTX=

'= cBG8\7::3 $887D8 JR9: 1B;BEG>D3 7J>?9;G`BE >;7:8A7>G9:3 $= F= %9JA>9:3 B> 7A=3BE8=3 &^[9;E3 )A7;B:E9: %;B883 MUUN=


199/360

2"% 1M;8 NBCG\ !$V$I

09JVAB VG:E >?B9;D C783 [9; \B3 7: B^B\RAG[GG9: 9[ ?9C >9 >?G:] 7V9J> 8J


200/360

7;>3 R9B>;D3 B>7VAD >?B >?B9;D E9B8 :9> EG8>G:HJG8? VB>CBB: >?B8B 8JV8RB?G: G>8 >B;\8 >?B;B G8 :9>?G:H >9 EB>B;\G:B C?B>?B; 7 HG@B: G:EG@GEJ7A 8?7AAVB EB>B;\G:B 8]GAA G:AB7;:G:H >9 VB >;7:8B^>J7A 9; I\9;B 7V8>;7ADQ >?B R9>B:>G7AG>GB8 [9; 7?G88]GAA= &;3 ?B HB:9\B \GH?> EB>B;\G:B 8]GAA8 G: ;B8G8>G:H >;7:8B^>J7AR7>?C7D83 9; >?B R9>B:>G7AG>D [9; 7?G8 A7>>B; 8]GAA= I+B:B>G8 ?7@B R7GE E63&AG>>AB 7>>B:>G9: >9 >?B :BD 9[ EB[G:G:H >?B A9HGDRG:H 9[ \B887HB8 G9:f7

8G:HAB EG[[B;B:?B DB8a9;a:9 7:8CB; >9 7 _JB8>G9: 9[ 7:D EBH;BB 9[D3 7> 7:D AB@BA 9[ 7V8>;7G9:= Q)J;;B:> >?B9;GB8 C?G ?B A7>B:> R9>B:>G7AG>D >9 7RRB7;G: >?B R?B:9>DRB=

/ \J8> ?7> >?B8B >?B9;GB8 8BB\ >9 \B 9[ AG>>AB G:>B;B8> J:>GA >?BR;9R9:B:>8 >;D >9 8RB 8 9[ >?B


201/360

c?7>B@B; >?B 8D8>B\3 7E7R>G@B


202/360

cB 7;B 89 VB[JEEABE VD A7:HJ7HB >?7> CB >?G:] 8>;7GH?>3 7:E G> G83 89\B>G\B83 >9 ;B\B\VB; >?7> CB 7;B ;B7AAD \7\\7A8= #?B BRG8>B\9A9HD9[ >?B d?B7;>e G8 >?7> 9[ 7:D :9:?J\7: \7\\7A= #?B E9B8 :9> 87D d\GA]eL 8?B8G\RAD 78 9J> I9; G8Q ?B; B:E 9[ 7: G:>B;


203/360

[A7R3 C?G


204/360

3 d#?B 29AB 9[ "9\7>G< )?7:HB G: $@9AJ>G9:3e @E2%=8(2#) MNXO3 MPb YTNaON=


205/360

2"- 5@8 ^


206/360

/:78\J


207/360

FB G> 87GE 7> 9:3 >?7> B\RG;G7 8?9C >?7> &g

Bateson StepsToAnEcologyofMind

Documents

Transcript of Bateson StepsToAnEcologyofMind